Some folks around here take umbrage at reasonable criticism.gandharva wrote:Second one. For sure.
/edit
Lulz at the downvote for my previous post. As if 2 years of disappointing customers would not be enough to proof it's truth.
Some folks around here take umbrage at reasonable criticism.gandharva wrote:Second one. For sure.
/edit
Lulz at the downvote for my previous post. As if 2 years of disappointing customers would not be enough to proof it's truth.
Renault have proven and publicly admitted they were lost so imo it's not unreasonable for those of us wishing to see Renault return to competitive form to place high expectations on Mario.godlameroso wrote:I didn't do it, but you were downvoted likely because you believe that Illmore will suddenly take them to the top and not more resources and monetary investment on Renault's part. They no longer throw money at Red Bull via Infinity, and in fact Red Bull now pays Renault for engines via TAG. That cash could easily go to their engine program.gandharva wrote:Second one. For sure.
/edit
Lulz at the downvote for my previous post. As if 2 years of disappointing customers would not be enough to proof it's truth.
You are two-thirds wrong. FOM will still pay RBR their share, and Total will still be a partner and sponsor or RBR.Blackout wrote: And the Total* and infinity and FOM money that used to go to RBR, will go to Renault.
Well seeing as how Infinity is an arm of Nissan which is owned by Renault I think whatever sum of money the parent company invested in Red Bull is being funneled right back into their own engine program. This + TAG money for engines, and Mario being persuaded to look at Renault at the Request of Red Bull leads me to believe they're still working together. There's certainly some politics involved, I think that all the stalling and backhanded dealings happened because Renault was planning to re-acquire Enstone for some time, and they wanted chassis data which Red Bull did not want to share. So Renault tried to leverage all the sponsorship it was tossing to Red Bull for chassis development as the reason they took so long with the development of the power unit. So now Renault has all of the money they invested in Red Bull back to develop the engine, plus their own chassis development team. I'm sure Red Bull has some contractual guarantees that they'd have more influence on when and how the power unit is developed, in exchange for Red Bull helping Renault with their 2017 chassis.ME4ME wrote:You are two-thirds wrong. FOM will still pay RBR their share, and Total will still be a partner and sponsor or RBR.Blackout wrote: And the Total* and infinity and FOM money that used to go to RBR, will go to Renault.
We can only speculate about Infiniti. They are partners with Renault now, but what the deal is worth, nobody knows. Over the years they were with RBR, they were title sponsor, for the quadripple championship winning team. Now with Renault they will initially be at the back, and maybe in the future be at the front. As far as i'm aware, they aren't even title sponsors. It's anyone's guess how much Infiniti contributes economically to Renault F1, but my guess is it's less than what they payed RBR for their billion dollar worth of annual TV-time.
Anyway, excuse me for the off-topic.
You didnt understand me. Obviously I was talking about the Renault part. I was comapring Renault's situation as a motorist with its new situation as a team. I said RBR was the F1 team, so RBR gets all the FOM revenues. Renault being 'just' an engine manufacturer and despites its contribution, gets nothing from that, or very little, and must rely on other (meager) sources. Now that Renault finally decided to do the new F1 the right way and run its own F1 team like Ferrari and Merc, it will get all the revenues that Renault generates... same for RBR, as usual.ME4ME wrote:You are two-thirds wrong. FOM will still pay RBR their share, and Total will still be a partner and sponsor or RBR.Blackout wrote: And the Total* and infinity and FOM money that used to go to RBR, will go to Renault.
Please explain exactly what restructuring happened at Renault that will suddenly improve the engine, beside hiring Mario Illien? Imho most of the restructuring was done on the chassis side and that won't help much to improve the engine. Sure this could in the long term improve the car, but this is not the car nor the team thread.Blackout wrote:With hte money Renault's parners (Total and Infinity) gave them...ME4ME wrote:They always did.godlameroso wrote:..and in fact Red Bull now pays Renault for engines..
Maybe gandharva didnt notice the changes that occured in the Renault camp in the last months... And he seems to think Renault cant built engine and only Illmor can save them.
Many things have changed in the las couple of months... Renault has its own team today and Its chassis team will be far more open and cooperative and will work with the engine team hand in hand...
What was true in a near past isnt true anymore.
Don't be such pessimist. Why would Renault stay in f1 if they have no vision? They clearly know where their deficit is. After all there are some very capable people and their ers is very good. I see no reason why their combustion efficiency could not reach Mercedes levels. It will not happen over night, but so didn't Mercedes make it happen over night.gandharva wrote: Please explain exactly what restructuring happened at Renault that will suddenly improve the engine, beside hiring Mario Illien? Imho most of the restructuring was done on the chassis side and that won't help much to improve the engine. Sure this could in the long term improve the car, but this is not the car nor the team thread.
Btw. what happened in the past is the ONLY true evidence one has. Everything else is pure speculation and/or wishful thinking.
I'm not a pessimist. I'm a realist. As soon as I start to see some progress at Renaults PU we can talk again.jure wrote:Don't be such pessimist. Why would Renault stay in f1 if they have no vision?gandharva wrote: Please explain exactly what restructuring happened at Renault that will suddenly improve the engine, beside hiring Mario Illien? Imho most of the restructuring was done on the chassis side and that won't help much to improve the engine. Sure this could in the long term improve the car, but this is not the car nor the team thread.
Btw. what happened in the past is the ONLY true evidence one has. Everything else is pure speculation and/or wishful thinking.
Ok, I see your point. It makes more sense nowBlackout wrote:You didnt understand me. Obviously I was talking about the Renault part. I was comapring Renault's situation as a motorist with its new situation as a team. I said RBR was the F1 team, so RBR gets all the FOM revenues. Renault being 'just' an engine manufacturer and despites its contribution, gets nothing from that, or very little, and must rely on other (meager) sources. Now that Renault finally decided to do the new F1 the right way and run its own F1 team like Ferrari and Merc, it will get all the revenues that Renault generates... same for RBR, as usual.ME4ME wrote:You are two-thirds wrong. FOM will still pay RBR their share, and Total will still be a partner and sponsor or RBR.Blackout wrote: And the Total* and infinity and FOM money that used to go to RBR, will go to Renault.
I ve put a (*) in font of (total) in order to recall that total will stay with RBR in 2016 but forgot to add that recall.