horse wrote:djones wrote:Could somebody please explain to an idiot what a crossplane engine is and what the advantages of this would be?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crossplane
I believe the advantage would be a "smoother" power delivery (not sure what this means in the real world), with the disadvantage of a heavier (possibly bulkier?) engine.
EDIT: A smoother power delivery implies less vibration. However, as the cars already withstand the vibrations of the flatplane, are there any advantages to a crossplane?
basically a cross plane is a perfectly balanced engine, but it has 50% more rotational inertia and it mostly pushs the crank up
since the crank is at 140mm from the floor of the car cross plane will be as low as the flat plane.
it will be abit heavier depending on how the conterweight is designed.
E=0.5*I*(w^2)
in 06 engine can go as far as 21,000 now they are limited to 18,000
which means w^2 is at 36/49 about 73%, interms means I can be 36% more, closer to 50%
the engine could rev less, which will have lower top speed, but ok in the sense that it could save even more fuel
if rev is unlimited flat plane is definately better
but if rev is unlimited bore size is limited, and they can make it rev as hard cross plane is likely
main advantages are it doesn't shake the car in to pieces, it holds revs better on partial throttle, so its easier to drive. power will be abit lower but not by that much
translate that interms of '10 rules the car will be about to just be driven off throttle in alot of places, instead of constant stab of throttle around a corner, saving fuel
Edit: numbers in calculation