I appreciate all the effort going into this but we're kidding ourselves to think that what you guys have worked to do is what is actually going on .. until you get some true flows from the real design (never gonna happen) we can only prod our way thru what we find.
Myself, I think the flow is going mostly under the car, not onto the top of the tray, creating a low pressure area under the car by sealing off airflow under the car. But what the hell do I know?
When I've done this in the past you would "grow" your way to a solution .. test this then test that, all the while observing what is happening vs what you wished happened. Eventually you get to a happy place or discard the idea. These guys built a car around this idea and that alone tells me it works ..
Last year Renault were a surprise. They had fresh aero ideas and worked at a relentless pace to bring them to the track all thru the season. Vastly different from what we came to expect from Briatore. And they all worked as designed right out of the box, just like Newey's work, maybe better (Newey had to redesign his Fduct but then he was two races earlier than Renault too).
I think we might even be experiencing the next Newey working now at Renault, driving these interesting ideas .. Renault ain't no stick in the mud anymore ..