2017 F1 general testing thread

Post here all non technical related topics about Formula One. This includes race results, discussions, testing analysis etc. TV coverage and other personal questions should be in Off topic chat.
kooleracer
kooleracer
24
Joined: 05 Jan 2012, 16:07

Re: 2017 F1 Pre-season testing February 27 - March 2/ March 7-10

Post

People please don't get in an argument about strat 1 or 2. Just listen to the gear shifts and listen to the revs of the engine. And compare it with Lewis Hamilton's 2016 pole lap. You can hear clearly that Bottas is not stressing the engine nor the gearbox at all. Also, if you look at the both cars body language and stearing input you can clearly see that the Ferrari is lighter on fuel during that lap and that the Ferrari engine is using higher revs.

Just compare both 2017 test laps see and hear for yourself. If you still think Bottas is in qualymode compare the 2017 test lap with the Hamilton pole lap from 2016. The difference in engine revs and gear shifts is night and day.

I think Mercedes might have a bigger lead than most people think. I think that Mercedes has a 0.4-0.6sec in the pocket compared to Ferrari. The Mercedes steering input are much more controlled, Bottas is mostly taking single jabs at the corner and the cars is less twitchy (nervous) than the Ferrari.
Last edited by kooleracer on 11 Mar 2017, 21:13, edited 1 time in total.
Irvine:"If you don't have a good car you can't win it, unless you are Michael or Senna. Lots of guys won in Adrian Newey's cars, big deal. Adrian is the real genius out there, there is Senna, there is Michael and there is Newey.They were the three great talents."

diemaster
diemaster
6
Joined: 07 Jun 2012, 16:59

Re: 2017 F1 Pre-season testing February 27 - March 2/ March 7-10

Post

don't panic, we will see soon :wink:

User avatar
Vanja #66
1618
Joined: 19 Mar 2012, 16:38

Re: 2017 F1 Pre-season testing February 27 - March 2/ March 7-10

Post

Comparison of number of laps in 2016 and 2017 (8 days of testing both years, if anyone suspects that's the reason):

Mercedes 1294-1096; 198 less
Ferrari 891-955; 64 more
Red Bull 817-684; 133 less
Williams 856-799; 57 less
Renault 776-597; 179 less
Haas 474-715; 241 more
Force India 779-785; 6 more
Toro Rosso 1049-584; 465 less (so, you want Renault power then?)
McLaren 710-425; 285 less
Sauber 838-788; 50 less

So, Mercedes definitely not as dominant in this aspect as last year. Toro Rosso deficit nearly half the number of laps. Ferrari and Haas only have some significant increase. McLaren... I won't say anything...
"If anyone was to ask for my opinion, which, I note, they're not..." - The Fellowship

#DwarvesAreNaturalSprinters
#BlessYouLaddie

bosanac1
bosanac1
3
Joined: 25 Jan 2007, 01:08

Re: 2017 F1 Pre-season testing February 27 - March 2/ March 7-10

Post

Long shot.

Does anyone know sector times of Kimi's 1:18.634?

ripper
ripper
39
Joined: 26 Aug 2015, 22:19

Re: 2017 F1 Pre-season testing February 27 - March 2/ March 7-10

Post

This is what I found:

S1 22.779
S2 29.454
S3 26.401

Marble
Marble
23
Joined: 11 Mar 2017, 22:30

Re: 2017 F1 Pre-season testing February 27 - March 2/ March 7-10

Post

Found this article with race-sim comparaisons and qualifying lap times with sector times :
http://blog.autoplus.fr/moncet/2017/03/ ... t-anthony/

Image
Last edited by Marble on 12 Mar 2017, 00:18, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
FrukostScones
162
Joined: 25 May 2010, 17:41
Location: European Union

Re: 2017 F1 Pre-season testing February 27 - March 2/ March 7-10

Post

Finishing races is important, but racing is more important.

giantfan10
giantfan10
27
Joined: 27 Nov 2014, 18:05
Location: USA

Re: 2017 F1 Pre-season testing February 27 - March 2/ March 7-10

Post

kooleracer wrote:People please don't get in an argument about strat 1 or 2. Just listen to the gear shifts and listen to the revs of the engine. And compare it with Lewis Hamilton's 2016 pole lap. You can hear clearly that Bottas is not stressing the engine nor the gearbox at all. Also, if you look at the both cars body language and stearing input you can clearly see that the Ferrari is lighter on fuel during that lap and that the Ferrari engine is using higher revs.

Just compare both 2017 test laps see and hear for yourself. If you still think Bottas is in qualymode compare the 2017 test lap with the Hamilton pole lap from 2016. The difference in engine revs and gear shifts is night and day.

I think Mercedes might have a bigger lead than most people think. I think that Mercedes has a 0.4-0.6sec in the pocket compared to Ferrari. The Mercedes steering input are much more controlled, Bottas is mostly taking single jabs at the corner and the cars is less twitchy (nervous) than the Ferrari.
Its comments like this that get me laughing.
Its blatantly obvious that you are a mercedes fan . steering input and cars body language tells you fuel loads? =D>
The Ferrari is using higher revs?
Compare the 2016 car to the 2017 car to figure out who is in qualy mode or not? i mean really?
then we have the theory that kimi missed the apex on turn 5 during his fast lap so the ferrari must understeer... funny thing is that Bottas also "missed " the apex on turn 5 during his fastest run and you guessed it in 2016 hamilton also "missed" the apex on his qualy run... newsflash folks the fastest way around every track does not always involve hitting the apex at every curve or turn and turn 5 just so happens to be one of those situations where hitting the apex and taking some curb gains you absolutely nothing in lap time.

Restomaniac
Restomaniac
0
Joined: 16 May 2016, 01:09
Location: Hull

Re: 2017 F1 Pre-season testing February 27 - March 2/ March 7-10

Post

giantfan10 wrote:
kooleracer wrote:People please don't get in an argument about strat 1 or 2. Just listen to the gear shifts and listen to the revs of the engine. And compare it with Lewis Hamilton's 2016 pole lap. You can hear clearly that Bottas is not stressing the engine nor the gearbox at all. Also, if you look at the both cars body language and stearing input you can clearly see that the Ferrari is lighter on fuel during that lap and that the Ferrari engine is using higher revs.

Just compare both 2017 test laps see and hear for yourself. If you still think Bottas is in qualymode compare the 2017 test lap with the Hamilton pole lap from 2016. The difference in engine revs and gear shifts is night and day.

I think Mercedes might have a bigger lead than most people think. I think that Mercedes has a 0.4-0.6sec in the pocket compared to Ferrari. The Mercedes steering input are much more controlled, Bottas is mostly taking single jabs at the corner and the cars is less twitchy (nervous) than the Ferrari.
Its comments like this that get me laughing.
Its blatantly obvious that you are a mercedes fan . steering input and cars body language tells you fuel loads? =D>
The Ferrari is using higher revs?
Compare the 2016 car to the 2017 car to figure out who is in qualy mode or not? i mean really?
then we have the theory that kimi missed the apex on turn 5 during his fast lap so the ferrari must understeer... funny thing is that Bottas also "missed " the apex on turn 5 during his fastest run and you guessed it in 2016 hamilton also "missed" the apex on his qualy run... newsflash folks the fastest way around every track does not always involve hitting the apex at every curve or turn and turn 5 just so happens to be one of those situations where hitting the apex and taking some curb gains you absolutely nothing in lap time.
All very true but when faced with history that tells us that Ferrari does test heavier and that they like to set a marker and that Mercedes likes to do the opposite. It's not beyond the realms of fantasy to think they may have done the same.

In the on-board the Mercedes DOES look heavier. That does suggest it's been the same this year. Nobody seems to think Mercedes is as far ahead as in previous years if in fact they are at all and TBH I think most feel more than happy about that. However going on previous seasons I think Ferrari have thrown the gauntlet down and Mercedes have got up out of their chair, looked at it and just shrugged their shoulders and sat back down and got on with THEIR testing plan.
Last edited by Restomaniac on 12 Mar 2017, 11:54, edited 4 times in total.

User avatar
etusch
131
Joined: 22 Feb 2009, 23:09
Location: Turkey

Re: 2017 F1 Pre-season testing February 27 - March 2/ March 7-10

Post

Vanja #66 wrote:Comparison of number of laps in 2016 and 2017 (8 days of testing both years, if anyone suspects that's the reason):

Mercedes 1294-1096; 198 less
Ferrari 891-955; 64 more
Red Bull 817-684; 133 less
Williams 856-799; 57 less
Renault 776-597; 179 less
Haas 474-715; 241 more
Force India 779-785; 6 more
Toro Rosso 1049-584; 465 less (so, you want Renault power then?)
McLaren 710-425; 285 less
Sauber 838-788; 50 less

So, Mercedes definitely not as dominant in this aspect as last year. Toro Rosso deficit nearly half the number of laps. Ferrari and Haas only have some significant increase. McLaren... I won't say anything...
Honda's 425 laps better than Honda's 2015 lap count 203. I think we must compare Honda with 2015

User avatar
etusch
131
Joined: 22 Feb 2009, 23:09
Location: Turkey

Re: 2017 F1 Pre-season testing February 27 - March 2/ March 7-10

Post

kooleracer wrote:
I think Mercedes might have a bigger lead than most people think. I think that Mercedes has a 0.4-0.6sec in the pocket compared to Ferrari. The Mercedes steering input are much more controlled, Bottas is mostly taking single jabs at the corner and the cars is less twitchy (nervous) than the Ferrari.
I don't know how someone can know rev level and fuel load from videos. I don't know how you find out 0.4- 0.6 sec in the pocket.
I don't think merc still leading. But if you calculation is true I am sure merc is behind Ferrari.
1.18.634 ferrari
1.19.310 merc.
There is more than 0.6. You can say because fuel load merc can go faster. But ferrari also can go faster. This season is the season merc beated by two team. Redbul and ferrari

mika vs michael
mika vs michael
-1
Joined: 27 Jan 2007, 01:35

Re: 2017 F1 Pre-season testing February 27 - March 2/ March 7-10

Post

Actually we don't know. We speculate...and this is the good part in testing and in preseason...everyone can say his jumbo mambo and then when the action begins in the first race...it does not matter anymore what I have said or you have speculated in the preseason...
So chill out guys and girls...enjoy freedom of speech...
"It is necessary to relax your muscles when you can. Relaxing your brain is fatal." Stirling Moss

I tried this and I had understeer, I tried that and I had oversteer, at the end of the corner I just run out of talent

zibby43
zibby43
613
Joined: 04 Mar 2017, 12:16

Re: 2017 F1 Pre-season testing February 27 - March 2/ March 7-10

Post

etusch wrote:
kooleracer wrote:
I think Mercedes might have a bigger lead than most people think. I think that Mercedes has a 0.4-0.6sec in the pocket compared to Ferrari. The Mercedes steering input are much more controlled, Bottas is mostly taking single jabs at the corner and the cars is less twitchy (nervous) than the Ferrari.
I don't know how someone can know rev level and fuel load from videos. I don't know how you find out 0.4- 0.6 sec in the pocket.
I don't think merc still leading. But if you calculation is true I am sure merc is behind Ferrari.
1.18.634 ferrari
1.19.310 merc.
There is more than 0.6. You can say because fuel load merc can go faster. But ferrari also can go faster. This season is the season merc beated by two team. Redbul and ferrari
Fuel loads have a significant impact on lap times. Mercedes consistently runs heavier fuel loads. You learn much more about the car that way. Ferrari, on the other hand, run considerably lighter. You can get a pretty good idea of how much fuel a car is running based on stint length and pace.

According to Auto Motor Sport:

Mercedes turned most of their laps with plenty of fuel on board. With respect to Bottas' 1.19.310 lap, after adjustments for fuel load and conservative power unit settings are made, it was calculated that a lap time of 1.18.0, or even slightly quicker, would have been possible.

That estimate/calculation did not account for broken/battered aerodynamic components. Nor did it take into consideration the fact that the car had not been "setup" or optimized for Bottas in any way. Neither Hamilton nor Bottas did much setup work at all during testing. Most of the work was purely data collection.

http://www.auto-motor-und-sport.de/form ... 52819.html

In sum, it is likely that Ferrari has a little extra in its pocket. However, with Mercedes opting to run heavy and "turned down" during testing, it is very likely that Mercedes has a considerable chunk of time in its pocket.

From what I've read, Mercedes still has a pace advantage over Ferrari, but it may be only be 3/4 tenths come Melbourne. There is also a source indicating that Mercedes was the fastest in terms of long run/race pace. Trying to track that down.

User avatar
GPR-A duplicate2
64
Joined: 07 Aug 2014, 09:00

Re: 2017 F1 Pre-season testing February 27 - March 2/ March 7-10

Post

etusch wrote:
kooleracer wrote:
I think Mercedes might have a bigger lead than most people think. I think that Mercedes has a 0.4-0.6sec in the pocket compared to Ferrari. The Mercedes steering input are much more controlled, Bottas is mostly taking single jabs at the corner and the cars is less twitchy (nervous) than the Ferrari.
I don't know how someone can know rev level and fuel load from videos. I don't know how you find out 0.4- 0.6 sec in the pocket.
I don't think merc still leading. But if you calculation is true I am sure merc is behind Ferrari.
1.18.634 ferrari
1.19.310 merc.
There is more than 0.6. You can say because fuel load merc can go faster. But ferrari also can go faster. This season is the season merc beated by two team. Redbul and ferrari
You reminded me of a good friend. :lol: It has been two, painfully long years since he preempted it.

Image

balintgabulya
balintgabulya
0
Joined: 05 Dec 2016, 23:42

Re: 2017 F1 Pre-season testing February 27 - March 2/ March 7-10

Post

Seriously the reasoning of some people here is pretty poor.

"Historical" fuel loads are not an argument today. You know.. historically when Ferrari made a car with a 0 and a 7 in its name they won both WCC and WDC. Ferrari 2017 WDC confirmed? 8) 8)