Crucial_Xtreme wrote:
As for diffuser stall happening, here is proof from Aero_A, who is F1 Aerodynamicist
http://imageshack.us/a/img593/2519/nzue.jpg
Read from bottom to top on this image
http://s18.postimg.org/vj7zod12x/aero_A1.jpg
Problems in Silverstone and then "on the fly" diffuser modifications in Germany show they were having problems with the diffuser. Was it stall? I can't say for sure obviously but it's not unheard of and confirmed by current F1 Aero Engineer.
Hmm i wouldn't use those guys as any strong support for this discussion. They're speculators.
I was expecting academia. Everything in f1 can be found in an academic paper. I don't like to use journos opinions as facts. As there is no way they will know if a difuser is stalling. What are they gonna do, take pictures behind their journo barriers to see it? lol
I can open a twitter account and call myself an NASA rocket scientist. I wont quickly jump on that band wagon.
We've seen in the past when cars have flipped instantaneously when the body raises off the ground or pitches excessively. That's a stalling floor. A stall is where there device is unloaded, the flow is disturbed completely.
There are localized regions of separation under a diffuser, this is the case with most things aero, and then there is a certain deviation in performance from optimum, but complete stall?
I don't see where that happens in a corner. As i said the car must be outside of its range, and no engineer is going to make something inadequate.
An inadequate diffuser will stall in the same corner every single lap. As long as you are repeating the conditions of stall it will do so. It's just not likely such a diffuser will be on any f1 car. especially with the design restrictions on diffuser height in the regulations. These regs were designed to prevent such things. I think the max height is 125mm. Any engineer making a diffuser that stalls in a corner may be an idiot or a genius, as that's very difficult to do and yet the ferrari board approves it. haha.
Stalling diffuser is not a good thing to use as a reason for some perceived under performance. The DRS talk probably got use carried away and we started stalling and flexing all kinda parts of the car.
But lets look into it anyway. For the diffuser to stall, maybe it has to be at a reduced speed from optimum. It's gonna be harder to stall when the energy is higher so lower speed regime is where you would look. So you can expect it at low speeds. Second thing to look at is the angle relative to the flow. This is almost impossible to change as the flow will always be parallel to the floor upstream.the floor will have to be out of ground effect range and the flow will have to be detached to have some change in angle with the throat and proflie. Also the throat to lenght to angle ratio will change once the floor starts coming up.
A next consideration is the cuts in the sides where the exhausts flow in. Something to look at, but it actually makes the floor harder to stall. it will vary performance yes, but stalling, i'm not sure sure.
Fourth thing is the turning vanes under the diffusers, we haven't seen Ferrari desperately changing these things. And you would naturally put more under the car if there were diffuser problems.
So before accepting the theories, i'd look at these aspects and do some background research on diffuser experiments.