Until Red Bull actually begin racking up front row lockouts and 1-2 finishes, that’s when we can begin to use the word dominant.
As it stands right now, the current RB16B is no better than the Mercedes cars of 2017 and 2018.
think it in the other way. in the times when merc do good car but rivals couldn't, being 1-2 is easy. but that merc are still good and you catched up them at that level, then, when you start to beat them, it is not that easy to be 1-2 anymore
There is a difference between having a better car and having a dominant car. A dominant car means that your 2nd driver ends up ahead of the rival teams 2nd driver in qualy or in the race. As Perez has been doing neither for the majority of the season so far, then I don't think that you can call it a dominant caretusch wrote: ↑15 Jul 2021, 18:26think it in the other way. in the times when merc do good car but rivals couldn't, being 1-2 is easy. but that merc are still good and you catched up them at that level, then, when you start to beat them, it is not that easy to be 1-2 anymore
And if Redbull beat the car that you see as best car, then absolutely Redbull car is better car.
Ryar wrote: ↑15 Jul 2021, 07:29In Styrian GP, Red Bull outqualified the next best car (Mercedes) by 0.194. In Austrian GP, Red Bull outqualified the next best car (McLaren) by 0.48. These are margins, traditionlly considered to be closely matched cars. Don't discount that the McLaren car wasn't good. No good car can qualify on the front row by such a thin margin. Being unable to manage the tyres in races, is a different proposition.cheeRS wrote: ↑14 Jul 2021, 23:57Only replying since you asked for it. Dominant is certainly subjective here. If a car wins every race by .25 sec it's still considered dominant, just as one that wins by 10 sec every race.Sieper wrote: ↑13 Jul 2021, 23:13Is it weird that I am a bit ticked off but that “dominant car” talk now that Max won a few races? When have Max and checo qualified P1 and P2 by a second on any non redbull car? Never. In fact, it was mostly just Max followed by 2 mercedesses so far. Last season we had several time Merc on 1 and 2, sometimes even by over a second.
I hope they can indeed turn also this deficit around.
Two things are true for any reasonable F1 fan:
1. Max is top tier, and definitely better than Checo overall
2. The RBR16B has proven to be the better car, at least up until now.
You can say what you want about Lewis' skill or whether it's just the car, but the fact is that rarely, rarely will any driver out qualify him by a large margin unless the car is clearly better. In France/Austria/Styria, Merc barely stood a chance. To me, that's dominant, as it probably is to most reasonable fans.
The other major factor that need to be considered, which often is getting ignored is, a driver in his late 30s, can't be as quick as a driver in his early 20s. That's just human anatomy. Lewis used to be ultra quick in his early 20s, where he used to pull some stunning qualifying laps that used to surprise a clinical operator like Button (by his own admission). So, who knows, if Max is put in that Mercedes, he might be producing the same results that he is producing with RB16B. Any margin less than 3 tenths, a greater driver can overcome with his own skills, like Alonso used to do in the RB dominance days to come close to beating Seb. A margin less than 3 tenths, it's hard to distinguish if it the car or the driver that is making the difference.
The difference, IMHO, is, Max is aruguably the best driver on the grid. He is young, has matured faster than any other F1 driver of any generation and has a competitive car, with which he is making the difference. May be a younger Lewis in the W12, could have been spoiling the party for Max in qualifying, where every last hundredth matter. Look at Federer in the past 5 years, he was the same guy that used to beat anyone in his way, but is a pale shadow of his former self. Same with Rossi. The dominant Mercedes cars of the past few years, have obviously masked the physical degradation of a driver like Lewis. No offense, he is still a top quality, but just not the same like in his 20s. So, it may not be so much with the cars after all.
I see your point, maybe saying "a mid level driver can achieve p2 in Q with a dominant car" explains it better but this and what you said also, hits hamilton too. I agree with that but many people in this forum will feel pain with this.Dee wrote: ↑15 Jul 2021, 19:49There is a difference between having a better car and having a dominant car. A dominant car means that your 2nd driver ends up ahead of the rival teams 2nd driver in qualy or in the race. As Perez has been doing neither for the majority of the season so far, then I don't think that you can call it a dominant caretusch wrote: ↑15 Jul 2021, 18:26think it in the other way. in the times when merc do good car but rivals couldn't, being 1-2 is easy. but that merc are still good and you catched up them at that level, then, when you start to beat them, it is not that easy to be 1-2 anymore
And if Redbull beat the car that you see as best car, then absolutely Redbull car is better car.
If car is A is 0.25s faster than car B, and car A and B driver pairs are each 0.3s apart, then car B's faster driver can be P2 and his team mate P4. Car A is still the dominant car if it wins lots of races.etusch wrote: ↑15 Jul 2021, 21:27I see your point, maybe saying "a mid level driver can achieve p2 in Q with a dominant car" explains it better but this and what you said also, hits hamilton too. I agree with that but many people in this forum will feel pain with this.Dee wrote: ↑15 Jul 2021, 19:49There is a difference between having a better car and having a dominant car. A dominant car means that your 2nd driver ends up ahead of the rival teams 2nd driver in qualy or in the race. As Perez has been doing neither for the majority of the season so far, then I don't think that you can call it a dominant caretusch wrote: ↑15 Jul 2021, 18:26
think it in the other way. in the times when merc do good car but rivals couldn't, being 1-2 is easy. but that merc are still good and you catched up them at that level, then, when you start to beat them, it is not that easy to be 1-2 anymore
And if Redbull beat the car that you see as best car, then absolutely Redbull car is better car.
"Car A is still the dominant car if it wins lots of races"Just_a_fan wrote: ↑15 Jul 2021, 22:01If car is A is 0.25s faster than car B, and car A and B driver pairs are each 0.3s apart, then car B's faster driver can be P2 and his team mate P4. Car A is still the dominant car if it wins lots of races.etusch wrote: ↑15 Jul 2021, 21:27I see your point, maybe saying "a mid level driver can achieve p2 in Q with a dominant car" explains it better but this and what you said also, hits hamilton too. I agree with that but many people in this forum will feel pain with this.Dee wrote: ↑15 Jul 2021, 19:49
There is a difference between having a better car and having a dominant car. A dominant car means that your 2nd driver ends up ahead of the rival teams 2nd driver in qualy or in the race. As Perez has been doing neither for the majority of the season so far, then I don't think that you can call it a dominant car
Car A driver A = 0s
Car B driver A = 0.25s
Car A driver B = +0.3s
Car B driver B = +0.55s
We know that, on average, Max and Lewis is noticeably quicker than his respective team mate. So above is one reason.
Of course, Max could be 0.25s quicker than Lewis and the cars are the same.
We can't know what the real performance relationship is between drivers in different cars because, well, they're in different cars.
Yes, over a second a lap ahead in qualifying and lapped everyone up to and including 3rd place. That's "in a race of its own, crushingly dominant", not just dominant.Zynerji wrote: ↑15 Jul 2021, 22:57Rewatched the 1987 Brittish GP on F1TV. And THAT is a display of a dominant car.
What we have now between Mercedes and RedBull is exponentially tighter than that season. Just listening to James Hunt's commentary makes it obvious that there were no competitors on the grid for that Williams, making any currently applicable statements to this end simply hyperbolic.
When we consider what other driver lived with Redbull;Dee wrote: ↑15 Jul 2021, 22:16"Car A is still the dominant car if it wins lots of races"Just_a_fan wrote: ↑15 Jul 2021, 22:01If car is A is 0.25s faster than car B, and car A and B driver pairs are each 0.3s apart, then car B's faster driver can be P2 and his team mate P4. Car A is still the dominant car if it wins lots of races.
Car A driver A = 0s
Car B driver A = 0.25s
Car A driver B = +0.3s
Car B driver B = +0.55s
We know that, on average, Max and Lewis is noticeably quicker than his respective team mate. So above is one reason.
Of course, Max could be 0.25s quicker than Lewis and the cars are the same.
We can't know what the real performance relationship is between drivers in different cars because, well, they're in different cars.
Here is my thing with that. If a car wins multiple podiums and races with only one of the drivers, than it's the driver making a difference. If both drivers are podiuming and winning multiple times then the car is dominant, in my view.
Lewis and Max are far ahead of their teammates, that is known, yet Bottas is on average the higher qualifier and the higher finisher this year, even though the Mercedes had a rocky start.
Perez is getting used to the car, I get that but he did not end up on the podium during either of the two Austrian races when Max won by over 17 seconds...
Some tracks have suited Merc, some have suited RB with it swinging RB's way recently.
I'm just interested to see what happens this wkd. I think the cars will be far closer together, performance wise
The Alpha Tauri white hubcaps and front wheel deflector (can we call it the fender yet?) are my absolute favorite!etusch wrote: ↑16 Jul 2021, 14:102022 car concept with Redbull Honda livery
https://www.instagram.com/p/CRYu0g7IMsb ... =copy_link
Yeah, that one looks good. I really hope the Red Bull do something interesting with their real nose, or reduce the amount of yellow by a lot, because that nose looks like a very big sausage kerb like this!Zynerji wrote: ↑16 Jul 2021, 14:40The Alpha Tauri white hubcaps and front wheel deflector (can we call it the fender yet?) are my absolute favorite!etusch wrote: ↑16 Jul 2021, 14:102022 car concept with Redbull Honda livery
https://www.instagram.com/p/CRYu0g7IMsb ... =copy_link