Inventor is my favourite CAD programme. The 2011 suite is fantastic.Jersey Tom wrote:I kinda liked Inventor more than Solidworks for handling large assemblies. Admittedly that was for spaceflight payloads and circa 2005.
Inventor is my favourite CAD programme. The 2011 suite is fantastic.Jersey Tom wrote:I kinda liked Inventor more than Solidworks for handling large assemblies. Admittedly that was for spaceflight payloads and circa 2005.
I wasn't claiming they didn't work, just that in FSAE they tend to not work.Carlos wrote:madtown77 - Haven't seen an aluminum monocoque in a few years? Here's one, built in Detroit; well - in the same neighborhood. Drive out to Race Car Replicas at 37575 Groesbeck Highway Clinton Township - they'll show you they work just fine
Uploaded with ImageShack.us
They build replica/clones of the Ford GT40, Porsche 917 and Ferrari P4. Granted they jet cut and weld the chassis, mostly because of the high volume of cars they build, but there is no reason why a classic riveted aluminum brake built monocoque
can't be done. I recommend lindsaybks.com " How to Do Aircraft Sheet Metal Work # 21893.
who of the studends will be able to perform expert welding?mep wrote:That’s true. The way they designed the chassis is somehow ...strange.
For FSAE I would prefer to see a well designed tube-frame chassis than gluing together some sandwich material.
In the end their car came up with a total weight of 150Kg and that would be a very good number for FSAE.
BTW.: I really like those chassis made from metal plates.
You can laser cut the plates, bend them and welt it together.
It's a very easy, fast and cheap way to make a chassis.
Many teams do a lot of their welding themselve and I have high respect for them.who of the studends will be able to perform expert welding?
a week will give you the basics ...but honestly speaking the truth starts with off position welding ...as soon as you´re dangling upside down in a awkward position unable to really see anything and you need to do a perfect TIG weld NOW you will admit that a studend capable of performing this would be well advised to look for a job as welder.mep wrote:Many teams do a lot of their welding themselve and I have high respect for them.who of the studends will be able to perform expert welding?
They just try it out and learn it by doing.
Most top teams do not and let some company, friend, sponsor or who ever do the welding.
There the welding is prolly done in the training workshop.
Btw. some students make a welding engineer and even those who do not should learn to weld during studies. I got a 1 week training course for welding during my studies and I did not made a special welding degree.