British GP 2011 - Silverstone

For ease of use, there is one thread per grand prix where you can discuss everything during that specific GP weekend. You can find these threads here.
Formula None
Formula None
1
Joined: 17 Nov 2010, 05:23

Re: British GP 2011 - Silverstone

Post

Please, let's not devolve into the "what a racer is and isn't" argument again. Button, Vettel, Hamilton, Alonso et al have their own style, method. Some make more passes. Some attempt more passes. Some are mellow. Some are more aggressive. All have shown they can win races and championships. Please, fanboys on all sides, give it a rest. You're diminishing this forum.

alvinkhorfire
alvinkhorfire
0
Joined: 06 Jul 2008, 19:47

Re: British GP 2011 - Silverstone

Post

Horner should have instructed Vettel to let Webber overtake him. After all, Vettel was much slower than Webber, at least due to KERS problem. It is entirely Vettel's bad luck.

The extra 3 points does not make much difference in Vettel's lead in driver standing, but it will be a major help for Webber to protect his 2nd place in the standing.

So much for team interest, as emphasized by Horner. It looks more like Vettel's interest to me.
jamsbong wrote:Webber had a bad start.
I am disappointed as well with Webber's second successive poor start from pole.
http://www.formula1.com/news/headlines/ ... 12293.html
Q: Mark, what happened at the start as it wasn't quite as good. It was still very good.
MW: Well Fernando and I spoke about it. The right hand side looked pretty good in those greasy conditions so that's the way it went today.
Had it been dry at the start, the left side of the track would have been better.

tok-tokkie
tok-tokkie
37
Joined: 08 Jun 2009, 16:21
Location: Cape Town

Re: British GP 2011 - Silverstone

Post

andartop wrote:Does anyone have any info from McLaren about Button's pit lane incident?
From what I saw it seemed like divine intervention;
First they radioed Button to come in so he could jump Webber.
The Red Bull S&%t crew heard that and called Webber in to react and protect his position.
Once Webber was in the pit lane it became apparent McLaren were bluffing as Button stayed out for another lap.
As the McLaren mechanics were going back in they dropped something that looked like a wheel nut, one of them had to chase it across the pit lane.
Then Button comes in on the next lap, and - surprise surprise - there's a wheel nut missing when he is released!

:lol:
It was not as you understand it.
The TV people (FIA?) did a really unsporting thing & broadcast the McLaren tactical decision which RBR heard & reacted to. McLaren then had to change their tactics & let Button do an extra lap - their pit crew had gone out for Button but the decision for another lap was made after that - it was not a bluff.
McLaren were really pissed-off about the broadcast of their tactics - very justifiably. When Button came in next lap they had to do a blinding quick stop to nullify Webbers undercutting them. They tried too hard & fluffed it.

-------------
McL deserve the fine. If that wheel had come off in the pit lane it would have been very dangerous. Fine is for unsafe practice irrespective of the racing consequences.

---------------
The 10 sec stop & go penalty on Schumacher was way excessive. Because a normal drive through is no penalty at all on the revised Silverstone Whiting has made a local rule that drive throughs wont be imposed & stop & goes will be. He should adjust the local rule to a 2 sec stop & go in place of a drive through & the normal 10 sec stop & go should become 12 or 15 secs so they both have similar effect to what happens at other tracks.

User avatar
raymondu999
54
Joined: 04 Feb 2010, 07:31

Re: British GP 2011 - Silverstone

Post

You do realize, of course, that the teams hear all radio messages anyways, and we (the fans) are the ones who only hear selected messages?
失败者找理由,成功者找方法

sAx
sAx
1
Joined: 08 Dec 2007, 13:38

Re: British GP 2011 - Silverstone

Post

Ray wrote:I will say though, after all this criticism of Vettel that I've been going on and on about, his interview on Top Gear tonight was fantastic. He's a really funny guy and very down to Earth. Great kid.
Hear hear! Great insight into his personality. His recalling of Nigel Mansell's brummie accent in conversation with Adrian Newey was high comedy!

sAx
Integrity, Trust, Respect.

Follow me: http://twitter.com/#!/sAx247

Mandrake
Mandrake
14
Joined: 31 May 2010, 01:31

Re: British GP 2011 - Silverstone

Post

archiebald wrote:
n smikle wrote:Vettel had trouble overtaking Hamilton? He tried for 8 laps and no cookie. He needs to improve on his on the spot thinking.
You are forgetting the fact that this is not just about Silverstone, Vettel has NEVER shown any major overtaking ability in his entire career.

In the same car, on the same tyres, Vettel would be totally outclassed.

No question that Vettel is quick on his own, but as he is in what is unquestionably the best car so no-one knows how quick.

But Vettel does not have the same wheel to wheel racing skills as Hamilton, Alonso, Kobayashi et al. Even Button, not known for aggressive driving has shown far more skills this season in this department than Vettel ever has.
I wonder if you watch different races than me....In the first stint, Vettel opened a gap of 8+ seconds over MW, he was so far ahead that MW was by no means affected anyhow by him, yet he couldn't follow. Alonso couldn't follow either, only the McLaren with Hamilton at the wheel came close.

As it dried up, the top 6 were doing exactly the same laptimes, there was no sign that the RedBull was the fastest car. Vettel could pull away from Webber who was chased down by Alonso, but the McLarens drove the same pace.

After the bad PitStop Vettel closed the gap to Hamilton, but wasn't too much faster than him....and even with DRS his car lacked the topspeed to follow. On the Hangar straight he only closed the gap slightly....how on earth should he have overtaken Hamilton? The one very good chance he had was brilliantly defended by Hamilton (closing the inner line enough to make Vettel lift off) Hamilton did not put a foot wrong and Vettel's car wasn't superior enough to come close enough....this has nothing to do with overtaking skills. In the same situation with Massa, Massa didn't defend as well as Hamilton and Vettel had learned from his mistake with Hamilton and blew past Massa with ease! So please, take off your rose coloured fanboy glasses and try to be objective!

I wonder though why Vettel's performance was so bad in the last stint, that wasn't world class performance.

Calculating the gap to Alonso and comparing it to the time lost in the pits + behind Hamilton it would have been a super exciting finish with both drivers were close together....Anyways, Alonso drove a mistake-free race with blistering performance in the dry, congrats!
Last edited by Mandrake on 11 Jul 2011, 11:54, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Traction
0
Joined: 14 Jun 2011, 11:50
Location: Cape Town, South Africa

Re: British GP 2011 - Silverstone

Post

Mandrake wrote:
archiebald wrote:
n smikle wrote:Vettel had trouble overtaking Hamilton? He tried for 8 laps and no cookie. He needs to improve on his on the spot thinking.
You are forgetting the fact that this is not just about Silverstone, Vettel has NEVER shown any major overtaking ability in his entire career.

In the same car, on the same tyres, Vettel would be totally outclassed.

No question that Vettel is quick on his own, but as he is in what is unquestionably the best car so no-one knows how quick.

But Vettel does not have the same wheel to wheel racing skills as Hamilton, Alonso, Kobayashi et al. Even Button, not known for aggressive driving has shown far more skills this season in this department than Vettel ever has.
I wonder if you watch different races than me....In the first stint, Vettel opened a gap of 8+ seconds over MW, he was so far ahead that MW was by no means affected anyhow by him, yet he couldn't follow. Alonso couldn't follow either, only the McLaren with Hamilton at the wheel came close.

As it dried up, the top 6 were doing exactly the same laptimes, there was no sign that the RedBull was the fastest car. Vettel could pull away from Webber who was chased down by Alonso, but the McLarens drove the same pace.

After the bad PitStop Vettel closed the gap to Hamilton, but wasn't too much faster than him....and even with DRS his car lacked the topspeed to follow. On the Hangar straight he only closed the gap slightly....how on earth should he have overtaken Hamilton? The one very good chance he had was brilliantly defended by Hamilton (closing the inner line enough to make Vettel lift off) Hamilton did not put a foot wrong and Vettel's car wasn't superior enough to come close enough....this has nothing to do with overtaking skills. In the same situation with Massa, Massa didn't defend as well as Hamilton and Vettel had learned from his mistake with Hamilton and blew past Massa with ease! So please, take off your rose coloured fanboy glasses and try to be objective!

I wonder though why Vettel's performance was so bad in the last sector, that wasn't world class performance.

Calculating the gap to Alonso and comparing it to the time lost in the pits + behind Hamilton it would have been a super exciting finish with both drivers were close together....Anyways, Alonso drove a mistake-free race with blistering performance in the dry, congrats!
+1 =D> 8)
Generally I don't care about what people say. I have to be clear with myself. When everything goes well, people celebrate you, when you make mistakes people criticize you.
Sebastian Vettel

tok-tokkie
tok-tokkie
37
Joined: 08 Jun 2009, 16:21
Location: Cape Town

Re: British GP 2011 - Silverstone

Post

raymondu999 wrote:You do realize, of course, that the teams hear all radio messages anyways, and we (the fans) are the ones who only hear selected messages?
As I understand it you are incorrect. The FIA hear all the messages. The teams are supposed to have confidential radio to their drivers. The FIA can choose what it makes available to the broadcasters. Usually it is delayed so other teams can gain no advantage from what is broadcast. In this case that is what did not happen.

However, I suppose the teams can simply have another radio tuned to the opposition's frequency. Are the messages encoded to prevent that?

spacer
spacer
9
Joined: 01 Nov 2009, 20:51

Re: British GP 2011 - Silverstone

Post

tokkie, I believe that was the way it used to be. This year those communications are public for alle broadcasters afaik.

Gerhard Berger
Gerhard Berger
-1
Joined: 20 Sep 2010, 11:17

Re: British GP 2011 - Silverstone

Post

Mandrake wrote: I wonder if you watch different races than me....In the first stint, Vettel opened a gap of 8+ seconds over MW, he was so far ahead that MW was by no means affected anyhow by him, yet he couldn't follow. Alonso couldn't follow either, only the McLaren with Hamilton at the wheel came close.

As it dried up, the top 6 were doing exactly the same laptimes, there was no sign that the RedBull was the fastest car. Vettel could pull away from Webber who was chased down by Alonso, but the McLarens drove the same pace.

After the bad PitStop Vettel closed the gap to Hamilton, but wasn't too much faster than him....and even with DRS his car lacked the topspeed to follow. On the Hangar straight he only closed the gap slightly....how on earth should he have overtaken Hamilton? The one very good chance he had was brilliantly defended by Hamilton (closing the inner line enough to make Vettel lift off) Hamilton did not put a foot wrong and Vettel's car wasn't superior enough to come close enough....this has nothing to do with overtaking skills. In the same situation with Massa, Massa didn't defend as well as Hamilton and Vettel had learned from his mistake with Hamilton and blew past Massa with ease! So please, take off your rose coloured fanboy glasses and try to be objective!

I wonder though why Vettel's performance was so bad in the last stint, that wasn't world class performance.

Calculating the gap to Alonso and comparing it to the time lost in the pits + behind Hamilton it would have been a super exciting finish with both drivers were close together....Anyways, Alonso drove a mistake-free race with blistering performance in the dry, congrats!
A few points...

Vettel was much faster than Hamilton - just look what happened once he got clean air after his pit stop.

Vettel's top speed was higher than Hamiltons according the F1 website. Even with the help of DRS he couldn't overtake.

The siuation with Massa was not the same. Massa was on 15 lap old softs, whilst Vettel was on brand new softs - of course he is going to be able to simply drive past him.

User avatar
Steven
Owner
Joined: 19 Aug 2002, 18:32
Location: Belgium

Re: British GP 2011 - Silverstone

Post

Jeffsvilleusa wrote:
Tomba wrote:Oh great. Now the FIA decided to fine McLaren and Sauber for the pit incidents.
I think losing wheels is inexcusable, intentional or not. It's literally a deadly hazard to everyone in proximity to the track. Sure, they didn't intend to commit the offense, but a penalty should be motivation to ensure it doesn't happen again.
Really, It's not like McLaren cares about a few thousand pounds of fine. They will be much more sorry for Button retiring due to their error. That is more than enough motivation for the team to make sure it doesn't happen again, again proving my point that a penalty in this case is useless.

myurr
myurr
9
Joined: 20 Mar 2008, 21:58

Re: British GP 2011 - Silverstone

Post

Tomba wrote:
Jeffsvilleusa wrote:
Tomba wrote:Oh great. Now the FIA decided to fine McLaren and Sauber for the pit incidents.
I think losing wheels is inexcusable, intentional or not. It's literally a deadly hazard to everyone in proximity to the track. Sure, they didn't intend to commit the offense, but a penalty should be motivation to ensure it doesn't happen again.
Really, It's not like McLaren cares about a few thousand pounds of fine. They will be much more sorry for Button retiring due to their error. That is more than enough motivation for the team to make sure it doesn't happen again, again proving my point that a penalty in this case is useless.
+1

Button pulled over as soon as he realised, there was nothing more that could be done beyond having minimum pit stop times of 6 or so seconds to take the pressure off (and that's ridiculous).

Mandrake
Mandrake
14
Joined: 31 May 2010, 01:31

Re: British GP 2011 - Silverstone

Post

Gerhard Berger wrote: A few points...

Vettel was much faster than Hamilton - just look what happened once he got clean air after his pit stop.

Vettel's top speed was higher than Hamiltons according the F1 website. Even with the help of DRS he couldn't overtake.

The siuation with Massa was not the same. Massa was on 15 lap old softs, whilst Vettel was on brand new softs - of course he is going to be able to simply drive past him.
Point 1: New tires, different story! We've seen it all season that the RedBull is faster out of the pits for the first 2-3 laps.

Point 2: He certainly didn't close significantly, so maybe that TopSpeed recording was while lapping or sth. similar. As he was behind Hamilton he didn't appear to have a top speed advantage.

Point 3: True, but then again he pulled the same maneuver on Hamilton only that Hamilton knew better how to defend....

I don't wanna say Vettel is a great overtaker, but to say he's rubbish because he didn't pass Hamilton yesterday is bulls***. He had no chance! He was never close enough, and it wasn't down to lack of ability!

User avatar
dren
226
Joined: 03 Mar 2010, 14:14

Re: McLaren MP4-26 Mercedes

Post

It is hard to say if the EBD restrictions really hindered Mclaren or if Ferrari's new updates are THAT much better. We'll see next race if Mclaren has a resurgence. Hamilton didn't look that bad, neither did Button, but the raw pace wasn't there. I think the Mclaren was hot blowing a lot more than the others.
Honda!

User avatar
Ciro Pabón
106
Joined: 11 May 2005, 00:31

Re: British GP 2011 - Silverstone

Post

Fanboys live in another world, people.

It's like talking to evangelists: you cannot convince them. Actually, you cannot convince any hardcore fan of anything. It's useless.

By falling into the trap of considering these issues worth of discussion we're allowing this site to become a wish washed version of F1Fanatics. Where is the technical input? Where are the analysis of the RACE, as opposed to the analysis of the behaviour, intentions and capabilities of a few drivers?

It was only me the guy who saw Perez and di Resta driving the race of their lives? It was only me who read what the drivers themselves wrote about the incidents? It's the same argument over and over:

Poster 1: "Hamilton lose again, na, na, na, na"
Poster 2: "Hamilton cannot lose and when he loses is not his fault"
Old timer 1: "Please, people, this is so boring..."
Poster 1: "Oh, yeah? You're the greatest SOB"
Poster 2: "Oh, yeah? Your momma is fat"

How I miss the Fanboy Ying Yang thread being used as a repository of these "posts", no matter which "side" they support! There was a time, I think, when circular discussions of this kind were not allowed to prosper, or at least there was a sincere effort to stop them cold in their irrelevant tracks.

Tomba, I think I have a partial answer to your question:

"Dans ce pays-ci, il est bon de tuer de temps en temps un amiral pour encourager les autres."
-- Voltaire, Candide --

It's not enough to fail at exams (although I share your point of view of "sin is its own punishment"), the teacher also have to give you a failed grade, in public.

Marshalls (and mods!) always have to think about that, I truly believe: "pour encourager les autres".
Ciro