f1rules wrote:I'm sorry, but ditch this car, most of the updates from last year to this is in the detail, should be transferrable
Front and rear brake ducts, drivetrain cover
If you look only at Jenson's performances last year, you wouldn't think that the McLaren was that good a car. Top 3 - 4 only rather than the out and out quickest for much of the season. McLaren's big problems seem to be a car with a narrow operating window, a driver with a narrow operating window, and a relative rookie whose pace is unknown. They have no real way of judging the pace of the car or assessing it's weaknesses. They don't know if Button is extracting all the pace the car has to give, or is leaving half a second on the table because he's not comfortable with the car. Do they need to take a backward step with the performance of the car to make it more to Button's liking so that he can extract more from it, and how will that affect Perez?
I'm British so I should be a Button fan. He's a nice guy and on his day can beat anyone. But I have a niggling doubt over his ability to develop a car over a season - has he ever successfully done so? Last year when it looked like McLaren were forcing Hamilton and Button to co-develop the setup for a given weekend all they seemed to achieve was slowing Hamilton down. In his championship winning year the cars pace seemed to get worse the more they developed the car, presumably in part due to Button's feedback and preferences.
I hope that Button and McLaren are able to prove me wrong, but the signals coming from the team do not bode well. I'm a Hamilton fan so will have to admit bias here, but I feel one of the biggest thing holding back McLaren's development of the car at the moment is in fact the drivers. With the pull rod front suspension setup changes take longer to implement leading to further woe whenever a driver goes the wrong way with the setup of the car - something Button appears prone to doing.
Contrast that to Mercedes who have a proven driver who is known for being able to adapt to the car, with a really solid and consistent second driver who also seems able to adapt, with a technical team that is starting to gel, and a good baseline car with arguably the best suspension system out there. They can just chase better aero numbers now knowing that the drivers will extract the additional pace and be able to give accurate guidance about the aero balance to help the engineers choose the right compromises.