Brazil GP 2008

Post here all non technical related topics about Formula One. This includes race results, discussions, testing analysis etc. TV coverage and other personal questions should be in Off topic chat.
The FOZ
The FOZ
0
Joined: 07 Feb 2008, 23:04
Location: Winterpeg, Canada

Re: Brazil GP 2008

Post

captainmorgan wrote:"Then Nakajima and I finished off our crashing love affair, and he took off my front corner." - DC

Put this guy on the BBC F1 coverage NOW!
Only DC...hahaha

I feel almost as bad for him as I do Massa. Wonder if Rosberg would be penalized for this? Can he be, since it's season's end?

alexbarwell
alexbarwell
0
Joined: 20 Mar 2008, 14:19
Location: London

Re: Brazil GP 2008

Post

Massa seems a pretty straight shooter and didn't deserve to miss out like this, but equally Hammy had been swindled by some bad decisions. I appreciate the outcome as Massa wins at home, Hammy gets the title, Ferrari can't complain as they have the manufacturer title. As for dubious driver moves in the finishing stages, you recall the same track last year when a certain driver was lined up for a good placing then suddenly got a box full of neutrals, then it recovered - just enough to finish behind and not trigger further politics.He lost by a whisker last year, he won by a whisker this year, both times clouded by a mass of inter-team bitching. Can we get back to racing next year?
I am an engineer, not a conceptualist :)

User avatar
vyselegend
0
Joined: 20 Feb 2006, 17:05
Location: Paris, France

Re: Brazil GP 2008

Post

The FOZ wrote:Whether it was intentional by Glock, whether he messed up, or whether it was simply track conditions and unavoidable, the long and the short of it is, the championship was decided less on the talent of Hamilton (he WAS passed by Vettel moments earlier, after all) and was decided more by a third party in Timo Glock, either through poor conditions, ineptitude, or conspiracy. That is what fans will dislike about how the WDC was decided.
OUCH! Was it much a "third party" decision than the FIA robbing points from Hamilton in Belgium, from Bourdais in Japan and giving them to Ferrari?! More than the FIA "forgetting" to punish Massa for his pit release in Valancia while the exact same move was punishable when it was making no difference in points in singapore?! Come on fanboy, I have just read you're watching F1 for just one year, watch it another few years and you will learn more about your favorite team, and the way they earn the points which makes them titles contenders in the last race every season... :wink:
Last edited by vyselegend on 02 Nov 2008, 21:36, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
ISLAMATRON
0
Joined: 01 Oct 2008, 18:29

Re: Brazil GP 2008

Post

The FOZ wrote:Whether it was intentional by Glock, whether he messed up, or whether it was simply track conditions and unavoidable, the long and the short of it is, the championship was decided less on the talent of Hamilton (he WAS passed by Vettel moments earlier, after all) and was decided more by a third party in Timo Glock, either through poor conditions, ineptitude, or conspiracy. That is what fans will dislike about how the WDC was decided.



The third party that has been trying to hand the Ferrari the championship all year was the FIA... Glock was in front of HAmilton on a gamble and lost the positions on that same gamble gone bad.

timbo
timbo
111
Joined: 22 Oct 2007, 10:14

Re: Brazil GP 2008

Post

The FOZ wrote:Simple. Lewis raced terribly until the last couple laps. By no means did he drive as hard as he could have, he merely rested on his laurels, not taking risks, just trying to maintain.

The guy who went on to win the WDC essentially half-assed the better part of the race. Only when he was about to lose did he get it in gear and actually start pushing like he can.

If this were based strictly upon wins, Felipe would have won, as a result of driving a solid, consistently fast race.

So would I rather see a type of racing where the drivers are racing their very hardest, going for it all the way, every day?

Yes. And you should, too.
This can be tweaked by giving more points advantage to the winner. And situations may be different, if it was all for the gold metal, we won't see something like Massa's race in China, that was also great to watch.

User avatar
megz
1
Joined: 14 Mar 2007, 09:57
Location: New Zealand

Re: Brazil GP 2008

Post

What a race. What a championship. Well done to Lewis on his WDC and I feel so sorry for Felipe having a WDC snaggled from just beneath his nose! Vettel raced superbly I actually yelled when he made that pass on Lewis it was superb. Fantastic season, bitterly disappointed to see the rules changed again but hey, thats F1.

Second congratulations to Felipe for his sportsmanship in the press conference, he's an excellent man.

User avatar
ISLAMATRON
0
Joined: 01 Oct 2008, 18:29

Re: Brazil GP 2008

Post

I love the irony of Massa &Ferrari thinking they won it all in Brazil only to have it snatched away in heartbreaking fashion... makes up for the SPA FIAsco a little.

Outstanding

and got DAMN is Hamilton's woman gorgeous! HE's won more than just the WDC!!!!

panchito401
panchito401
0
Joined: 14 Sep 2008, 03:04

Re: Brazil GP 2008

Post

After watching that race, I would've been happy to see it go either way. But wow wow wow. That was an awesome race to watch, and a great finale to the season. wow.

-f

User avatar
ISLAMATRON
0
Joined: 01 Oct 2008, 18:29

Re: Brazil GP 2008

Post

timbo wrote:
The FOZ wrote:Simple. Lewis raced terribly until the last couple laps. By no means did he drive as hard as he could have, he merely rested on his laurels, not taking risks, just trying to maintain.

The guy who went on to win the WDC essentially half-assed the better part of the race. Only when he was about to lose did he get it in gear and actually start pushing like he can.

If this were based strictly upon wins, Felipe would have won, as a result of driving a solid, consistently fast race.

So would I rather see a type of racing where the drivers are racing their very hardest, going for it all the way, every day?

Yes. And you should, too.
This can be tweaked by giving more points advantage to the winner. And situations may be different, if it was all for the gold metal, we won't see something like Massa's race in China, that was also great to watch.
KIMI gifting MAssa a position was great to watch? I dont understand that in the least. The medal system could quite possibly get rid of most of this team orders BS. MAssa gifting KIMI the win in Brazil last year was equally as disgusting. IF it were a medal system the stewards would never have BS's in SPA(if they had even the slihtest bit of integrity) and HAmilton would have been driving for the win today, not for fifth. LH was driving only to bring the car home and I hate that, the medal system would do away with that crap.
Last edited by ISLAMATRON on 02 Nov 2008, 21:44, edited 1 time in total.

The FOZ
The FOZ
0
Joined: 07 Feb 2008, 23:04
Location: Winterpeg, Canada

Re: Brazil GP 2008

Post

vyselegend wrote:
The FOZ wrote:Whether it was intentional by Glock, whether he messed up, or whether it was simply track conditions and unavoidable, the long and the short of it is, the championship was decided less on the talent of Hamilton (he WAS passed by Vettel moments earlier, after all) and was decided more by a third party in Timo Glock, either through poor conditions, ineptitude, or conspiracy. That is what fans will dislike about how the WDC was decided.
OUCH! Was it much a "third party" decision than the FIA robbing points from Hamilton in Belgium, from Bourdais in Japan and giving them to Ferrari?! More than the FIA "forgetting" to punish Massa for his pit release in Valancia while the exact same move was punishable when it was making no difference in points in singapore?! Come on fanboy, I have just read you're watching F1 for just one year, watch it another few years and you will learn more about your favorite team, and the way they earn the points which makes them titles contenders in the last race every season... :wink:
Settle down, Beavis.

I've been watching every race this season, several last season near the end, but I've been a fan since...put it this way, I've had a poster of Schumacher on my wall for the past 5 years now.

No other team has been so consistently near the top as Ferrari, period. It only follows that they'd be involved in more dramatic crap. Funny how that is when you're near the top of the heap every time...

The FOZ
The FOZ
0
Joined: 07 Feb 2008, 23:04
Location: Winterpeg, Canada

Re: Brazil GP 2008

Post

ISLAMATRON wrote:KIMI gifting MAssa a position was great to watch? I dont understand that in the least. The medal system could quite possibly get rid of most of this team orders BS. MAssa gifting KIMI the win in Brazil last year was equally as disgusting.
Have you ever been asked by your boss to do something you don't like? Keep in mind, Kimi and Felipe don't own the cars or the team, nor put up the hundreds of millions of dollars it takes to keep the team going. At the end of the day, their duty is to the team, not themselves.

timbo
timbo
111
Joined: 22 Oct 2007, 10:14

Re: Brazil GP 2008

Post

ISLAMATRON wrote:KIMI gifting MAssa a position was great to watch? I dont understand that in the least. The medal system could quite possibly get rid of most of this team orders BS. MAssa gifting KIMI the win in Brazil last year was equally as disgusting.
In what way? Look at last year, Massa would still need to give position to Kimi. Likewise if in China Kimi and Massa were 1st and 2nd, don't you think Kimi would give up his position? The only ultinate way to have no team play is to have a single driver per team, plain and simple.

User avatar
ISLAMATRON
0
Joined: 01 Oct 2008, 18:29

Re: Brazil GP 2008

Post

The FOZ wrote:
ISLAMATRON wrote:KIMI gifting MAssa a position was great to watch? I dont understand that in the least. The medal system could quite possibly get rid of most of this team orders BS. MAssa gifting KIMI the win in Brazil last year was equally as disgusting.
Have you ever been asked by your boss to do something you don't like? Keep in mind, Kimi and Felipe don't own the cars or the team, nor put up the hundreds of millions of dollars it takes to keep the team going. At the end of the day, their duty is to the team, not themselves.
I am my own boss! I understand they do as the team tells them, as they should... but there should be no inceive for team orders... make them irrelavent. And the MEdal system(or something like it 1000 points for a win) would do away with it. And if the stakes for winning were so much higher, maybe guy like you wouldnt be so happy at accepting team orders, as ok.

User avatar
Shaddock
0
Joined: 07 Nov 2006, 14:39
Location: UK

Re: Brazil GP 2008

Post

The FOZ wrote:Whether it was intentional by Glock, whether he messed up, or whether it was simply track conditions and unavoidable, the long and the short of it is, the championship was decided less on the talent of Hamilton (he WAS passed by Vettel moments earlier, after all) and was decided more by a third party in Timo Glock, either through poor conditions, ineptitude, or conspiracy. That is what fans will dislike about how the WDC was decided.
You must have a very bitter taste in your mouth. It was a great race a fantastic end to the season. Both McLarens had a low downforce setup and would struggle in the wet compared to their rivals. The rain makes for exciting races with unexpected outcomes, do drivers come in this lap or the next or stay out on dry tyres. There was no conspiracy, it was just raining, and getting harder, once the tyre temp drops below a certain level you get a massive performance fall off from them. Glock gambled on staying out and pinching a couple of places, he was half a lap from that bet paying off.

mx_tifoso
mx_tifoso
0
Joined: 30 Nov 2006, 05:01
Location: North America

Re: Brazil GP 2008

Post

Please don't start guys, keep it clean and respectful.

No need to offend anyone, thing, or team.
Forum guide: read before posting

"You do it, then it's done." - Kimi Räikkönen

Por las buenas soy amigo, por las malas soy campeón.