2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

For ease of use, there is one thread per grand prix where you can discuss everything during that specific GP weekend. You can find these threads here.
User avatar
zoroastar
7
Joined: 31 Aug 2017, 08:04

Re: 2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

Post

anybody that thinks the rb19 is more dominant than the 2014 &15 merc,( after only 2 races) clearly didnt watch f1 in 2014 &15. or are so enamored with lewis that they refuse to believe that he could be wrong. hes clearly talking about cars that he has raced AGAINST, and doesnt have a clue what it was like for every other driver besides him and rosberg. welcome to reality lewis, looks like your endless string of luck has finally run out. : o

I will agree that the rb19 is a more complete package. the mercs were the only team that really understood the turbo hybrids from the start. hard to say what the redbull would have done with that PU in the back.

rijtuig
rijtuig
0
Joined: 14 Oct 2022, 15:19

Re: 2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

Post

Well, RB is also the only team that understood the new era from the start. Let us not forget that the championship was decided 4 races before the end of the season.

User avatar
vanburin
1
Joined: 28 Feb 2017, 19:33

Re: 2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

Post

rijtuig wrote:
23 Mar 2023, 10:55
Well, RB is also the only team that understood the new era from the start. Let us not forget that the championship was decided 4 races before the end of the season.
And that was with early season reliability issues. Max didn't even finish 2 of the first 3 races.

Though all of this talk of "which car is more dominant" is a bit bonkers, and frankly can be just subjective enough that it would be an endless debate.

It's a shame that Australia isn't this weekend, to divert our attention! :lol:

AR3-GP
AR3-GP
365
Joined: 06 Jul 2021, 01:22

Re: 2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

Post

vanburin wrote:
23 Mar 2023, 14:26
rijtuig wrote:
23 Mar 2023, 10:55
Well, RB is also the only team that understood the new era from the start. Let us not forget that the championship was decided 4 races before the end of the season.
And that was with early season reliability issues. Max didn't even finish 2 of the first 3 races.

Though all of this talk of "which car is more dominant" is a bit bonkers, and frankly can be just subjective enough that it would be an endless debate.

It's a shame that Australia isn't this weekend, to divert our attention! :lol:
If you think that's bad, the 4 week break between Australia and Baku is just scandalous....

Turkey and Portimao would have loved to have the GP.
Last edited by AR3-GP on 23 Mar 2023, 19:55, edited 1 time in total.
A lion must kill its prey.

User avatar
Chuckjr
38
Joined: 24 Feb 2012, 08:34
Location: USA

Re: 2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

Post

zoroastar wrote:
23 Mar 2023, 09:59
anybody that thinks the rb19 is more dominant than the 2014 &15 merc,( after only 2 races) clearly didnt watch f1 in 2014 &15. or are so enamored with lewis that they refuse to believe that he could be wrong. hes clearly talking about cars that he has raced AGAINST, and doesnt have a clue what it was like for every other driver besides him and rosberg. welcome to reality lewis, looks like your endless string of luck has finally run out. : o

I will agree that the rb19 is a more complete package. the mercs were the only team that really understood the turbo hybrids from the start. hard to say what the redbull would have done with that PU in the back.
Very true. Good comments there.

Honestly, I think Merc was turning their engine down back then — meaning, their advantage was much larger than the public ever realized. There have been some good arguments over the years to support this idea and a lot of them are lost in the thousands of pages of endless threads here. Merc had such advantage, they only used enough to ensure winning. In fact, I remember in an interview with Lewis shortly after it was realized how much advantage they had in the W05, and he kinda smirked in the interview when asked about their engine, and said they not only were indeed most powerful, but had more engine updates coming. Nobody could believe this was possible because they were so much faster with such a huge engine advantage, but Merc did in fact bring more speed week after week that whole first and second years of the engine rule changes. Untouchable. Had they lit the wick entirely, they would have been crippled by the FIA in some way to keep the sport from becoming embarrassingly lopsided (tho it already was imo), and uninteresting to anyone but fans of Merc and their drivers. I was a Schumacher fan so I knew how great it was to have a favorite driver untouchable, and how much you don’t care what others think about it.

I don’t see that kind former Merc level of overwhelming power/dominance in the RB. AM is really right there, they simply have a top speed/drag issue, but they claim the design is so good, they have huge developments in the pipeline building on their concept that address their drag, and they have something like 40% more wind tunnel time this year due to their finishing position last year. Those updates and time in the wind tunnel will result in some serious speed to be found, and imo, more than RB will find, but I may be wrong in that idea. Just my gut after watching this circus for far to long. Lol

Imo, RB have simply mastered this aero reg, and are reaping the rewards for the first half of the season. But AM, Ferrari, and possibly Merc, should be much more challenging by mid season. There was no hope of that in 2014 and on for years after. That won’t be the case with his aero set much like when Macca developed the coanda effect and RB found a way to beat them at their own game. There will be some of that since it’s a lot easier to see aero updates that work than engine updates.

I’ve read the theory on this very website actually, that Newey, because he spent so much time on his Aston Martin pet project the Valkyrie — which was based on Bernoulli effect — had a massive advantage of understanding this phenomena going into the new aero regs. Similarly, Merc had a massive advantage of all their worldwide R&D working with turbos long before the engine formulae was changed that fateful year of 2014. Practically speaking, and on that point, I don’t think one or two clever engineers at RB can compare or match the empire and brain trust that drove and motivated the W05-... efforts considering the additional engine advantage they held back until needed, and the hopelessness of other teams catching them anytime soon. I don’t see that kind of dominance in the RB this year or next to come.

I don’t think RB can turn it on or off like one could with an engine mode. Tho it is rumored, and some graphs here on this thread render, that RB have a bit of advantage harvesting at the top end speed that other teams don’t share atp.
Watching F1 since 1986.

User avatar
zoroastar
7
Joined: 31 Aug 2017, 08:04

Re: 2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

Post

Chuckjr wrote:
23 Mar 2023, 19:55
zoroastar wrote:
23 Mar 2023, 09:59
anybody that thinks the rb19 is more dominant than the 2014 &15 merc,( after only 2 races) clearly didnt watch f1 in 2014 &15. or are so enamored with lewis that they refuse to believe that he could be wrong. hes clearly talking about cars that he has raced AGAINST, and doesnt have a clue what it was like for every other driver besides him and rosberg. welcome to reality lewis, looks like your endless string of luck has finally run out. : o

I will agree that the rb19 is a more complete package. the mercs were the only team that really understood the turbo hybrids from the start. hard to say what the redbull would have done with that PU in the back.
Very true. Good comments there.

Honestly, I think Merc was turning their engine down back then — meaning, their advantage was much larger than the public ever realized. There have been some good arguments over the years to support this idea and a lot of them are lost in the thousands of pages of endless threads here. Merc had such advantage, they only used enough to ensure winning. In fact, I remember in an interview with Lewis shortly after it was realized how much advantage they had in the W05, and he kinda smirked in the interview when asked about their engine, and said they not only were indeed most powerful, but had more engine updates coming. Nobody could believe this was possible because they were so much faster with such a huge engine advantage, but Merc did in fact bring more speed week after week that whole first and second years of the engine rule changes. Untouchable. Had they lit the wick entirely, they would have been crippled by the FIA in some way to keep the sport from becoming embarrassingly lopsided (tho it already was imo), and uninteresting to anyone but fans of Merc and their drivers. I was a Schumacher fan so I knew how great it was to have a favorite driver untouchable, and how much you don’t care what others think about it.

I don’t see that kind former Merc level of overwhelming power/dominance in the RB. AM is really right there, they simply have a top speed/drag issue, but they claim the design is so good, they have huge developments in the pipeline building on their concept that address their drag, and they have something like 40% more wind tunnel time this year due to their finishing position last year. Those updates and time in the wind tunnel will result in some serious speed to be found, and imo, more than RB will find, but I may be wrong in that idea. Just my gut after watching this circus for far to long. Lol

Imo, RB have simply mastered this aero reg, and are reaping the rewards for the first half of the season. But AM, Ferrari, and possibly Merc, should be much more challenging by mid season. There was no hope of that in 2014 and on for years after. That won’t be the case with his aero set much like when Macca developed the coanda effect and RB found a way to beat them at their own game. There will be some of that since it’s a lot easier to see aero updates that work than engine updates.

I’ve read the theory on this very website actually, that Newey, because he spent so much time on his Aston Martin pet project the Valkyrie — which was based on Bernoulli effect — had a massive advantage of understanding this phenomena going into the new aero regs. Similarly, Merc had a massive advantage of all their worldwide R&D working with turbos long before the engine formulae was changed that fateful year of 2014. Practically speaking, and on that point, I don’t think one or two clever engineers at RB can compare or match the empire and brain trust that drove and motivated the W05-... efforts considering the additional engine advantage they held back until needed, and the hopelessness of other teams catching them anytime soon. I don’t see that kind of dominance in the RB this year or next to come.

I don’t think RB can turn it on or off like one could with an engine mode. Tho it is rumored, and some graphs here on this thread render, that RB have a bit of advantage harvesting at the top end speed that other teams don’t share atp.
yeah i agree, the trump card that redbull have is definitely newey. they dont bring very many updates that "dont work". that being said, im going to be very suspicious of redbull if they go the whole year, keeping this gap, with 40% less wind tunnel time. if that is the case, something aint right in milton keynes haha

User avatar
chrisc90
41
Joined: 23 Feb 2022, 21:22

Re: 2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

Post

Just imagine the upgrades next year when they get a increase in tunnel time too!!
Mess with the Bull - you get the horns.

User avatar
PlatinumZealot
559
Joined: 12 Jun 2008, 03:45

Re: 2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

Post

The dominance ratios of the RB19 to the W05 of 2014 is not that much different when you do the math....

Gap of dominant car to next divided by gap of next car to backmarker...
🖐️✌️☝️👀👌✍️🐎🏆🙏

Racing Green in 2028

nowaysthatsreal
nowaysthatsreal
0
Joined: 26 Feb 2023, 19:41

Re: 2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

Post

Not really hard to say AMR has merc PU with few ex-RB engineers and AMR is ahead. RB with that PU would have dominated the races too.
zoroastar wrote:
23 Mar 2023, 09:59
anybody that thinks the rb19 is more dominant than the 2014 &15 merc,( after only 2 races) clearly didnt watch f1 in 2014 &15. or are so enamored with lewis that they refuse to believe that he could be wrong. hes clearly talking about cars that he has raced AGAINST, and doesnt have a clue what it was like for every other driver besides him and rosberg. welcome to reality lewis, looks like your endless string of luck has finally run out. : o

I will agree that the rb19 is a more complete package. the mercs were the only team that really understood the turbo hybrids from the start. hard to say what the redbull would have done with that PU in the back.

LM10
LM10
121
Joined: 07 Mar 2018, 00:07

Re: 2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

Post

nowaysthatsreal wrote:
24 Mar 2023, 12:12
Not really hard to say AMR has merc PU with few ex-RB engineers and AMR is ahead. RB with that PU would have dominated the races too.
Yes, right. Because RB engineers are the only ones capable of building a winner car.

nowaysthatsreal
nowaysthatsreal
0
Joined: 26 Feb 2023, 19:41

Re: 2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

Post

LM10 wrote:
24 Mar 2023, 15:37
nowaysthatsreal wrote:
24 Mar 2023, 12:12
Not really hard to say AMR has merc PU with few ex-RB engineers and AMR is ahead. RB with that PU would have dominated the races too.
Yes, right. Because RB engineers are the only ones capable of building a winner car.
I think they have built top cars when PU rules have been stable and there have been restrictions on PU/engine development. They have come out on top when it is all about aero. except brawn double diffuser stuff, they were on top mostly.

User avatar
zoroastar
7
Joined: 31 Aug 2017, 08:04

Re: 2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

Post

all i want to know is when will Newey be retiring.. ( :

User avatar
Sieper
73
Joined: 14 Mar 2017, 15:19

Re: 2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

Post

PlatinumZealot wrote:
24 Mar 2023, 01:46
The dominance ratios of the RB19 to the W05 of 2014 is not that much different when you do the math....

Gap of dominant car to next divided by gap of next car to backmarker...
Yes, that is an interesting comparison. But also, 1,5 second to the next team is 1,5 second. How close the rest of the pack is doesn’t really matter, you still have your 1,5 seconds. That’s two major errors and a minor one in your qualy hotlap and you still start from P2.

ChrisF1
ChrisF1
7
Joined: 28 Feb 2013, 21:48

Re: 2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

Post

Sieper wrote:
25 Mar 2023, 13:29
PlatinumZealot wrote:
24 Mar 2023, 01:46
The dominance ratios of the RB19 to the W05 of 2014 is not that much different when you do the math....

Gap of dominant car to next divided by gap of next car to backmarker...
Yes, that is an interesting comparison. But also, 1,5 second to the next team is 1,5 second. How close the rest of the pack is doesn’t really matter, you still have your 1,5 seconds. That’s two major errors and a minor one in your qualy hotlap and you still start from P2.
That's how Rosberg almost won a title in 2014. He could be scruffy and still start P2.

mendis
mendis
19
Joined: 03 Jul 2022, 16:12

Re: 2023 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix - Jeddah, March 17 - 19

Post

ChrisF1 wrote:
26 Mar 2023, 09:59
Sieper wrote:
25 Mar 2023, 13:29
PlatinumZealot wrote:
24 Mar 2023, 01:46
The dominance ratios of the RB19 to the W05 of 2014 is not that much different when you do the math....

Gap of dominant car to next divided by gap of next car to backmarker...
Yes, that is an interesting comparison. But also, 1,5 second to the next team is 1,5 second. How close the rest of the pack is doesn’t really matter, you still have your 1,5 seconds. That’s two major errors and a minor one in your qualy hotlap and you still start from P2.
That's how Rosberg almost won a title in 2014. He could be scruffy and still start P2.
He could smoke a set of tyres on Lap 1, get back to pits to change them, go plum last and then do "walk in the park" to finish 2nd.