You can bet your sweet patootie that Max will try something in T1. McLaren boys need to make sure it’s not race ending since they’ll have the pace to recover any lost positions. Max knows that they have more to lose in this situation so he’ll race accordingly.
Admit what?chrisc90 wrote: ↑21 Jul 2024, 09:57Interesting thing to admit....if its true.
McLaren team principal Andrea Stella is surprised over how a brake drum hole “escalated” to become a major Formula 1 paddock talking point, after Red Bull allegedly raised the alarm.
- #AMuS reported that Red Bull had spotted a brake drum hole on the McLaren MCL38 which needs to be covered after practice to comply with the regulations, but McLaren and another team had not re-covered them at recent races.
- The holes were said to have been re-covered by tape at the Austria and British rounds, with Stella confirming to Sky F1 that McLaren turned to that tactic.
- Stella validated talk that the FIA had been in touch to clarify that the holes needed covering, with Red Bull reportedly having alerted the governing body, fearing an extra cooling mechanism was being created against the regulations.
He said, “Actually, this matter is very simple. This is a hole to access a sensor and we got the clarification from the FIA that this hole is not allowed and we just taped it. It’s a very, very simple matter which for some reason seems to have escalated to become a topic in the paddock. But nothing of that kind.”
VIA: [PLANET F1: https://www.planetf1.com/news/mclaren-e ... 3pq7y2i7Ug]
Well its regulation that any holes are covered in the brake drum/cake tins i'd say from reading that article??FittingMechanics wrote: ↑21 Jul 2024, 11:44
Admit what?
Seems that it is a complete non factor as McLaren was very fast in Hungary.
Just feel for Horner's position - the team are coming under pressure from all directions. You know when he starts insinuating others are doing illegal things, it's called "projection". They're doing stuff all the time which is "borderline" and if another team is getting the better of them , well they just must be cheating. Expect the front wing deflection query to go away, at least for 2024, with a possible clarification or an adjustment to the rules interpretation for 2025.chrisc90 wrote: ↑21 Jul 2024, 11:54Well its regulation that any holes are covered in the brake drum/cake tins i'd say from reading that article??FittingMechanics wrote: ↑21 Jul 2024, 11:44
Admit what?
Seems that it is a complete non factor as McLaren was very fast in Hungary.
I think there may yet be a clarification around the wings, but I don't think the FIA are in a hurry. They wouldn't be fitting cameras to analyse flex unless they want to act in it. But maybe not this season.BMMR61 wrote: ↑21 Jul 2024, 12:15Just feel for Horner's position - the team are coming under pressure from all directions. You know when he starts insinuating others are doing illegal things, it's called "projection". They're doing stuff all the time which is "borderline" and if another team is getting the better of them , well they just must be cheating. Expect the front wing deflection query to go away, at least for 2024, with a possible clarification or an adjustment to the rules interpretation for 2025.chrisc90 wrote: ↑21 Jul 2024, 11:54Well its regulation that any holes are covered in the brake drum/cake tins i'd say from reading that article??FittingMechanics wrote: ↑21 Jul 2024, 11:44
Admit what?
Seems that it is a complete non factor as McLaren was very fast in Hungary.
Just my opinion.
The competitive situation is very good for business, George winning the GP the week before Silverstone filled the stands in a difficult year for the BRDC. Only my opinion but one this will go away. As the cake tin hole was summarily dismissed. I'm starting to understand why Zak is being drawn into verbal stouches with Christian Horner - he's a cheeky ba%#*&rd and it gets under people's skins. Brown has always contended that having two teams is a very precarious thing for the FIA to keep on the top of. I'd sooner we have a clean and competitive fight to the end of the season.
Red Bull/Horner looking at what other teams are doing is exactly the same as what every other team does on the grid. Its the nature of the sport and if you are not doing things by the book, ANY team will jump on it and complain. Mercedes did it in 2022 with the floor and being hugely vocal about it, 2021 with the pit stops where nobody could get close to a Red Bull stop, multiple teams working together to work out what Ferrari were doing with their PU. Its all a big piranha tank and everyone is out to get to each other. Remember there is more than the battle on track.BMMR61 wrote: ↑21 Jul 2024, 12:15Just feel for Horner's position - the team are coming under pressure from all directions. You know when he starts insinuating others are doing illegal things, it's called "projection". They're doing stuff all the time which is "borderline" and if another team is getting the better of them , well they just must be cheating. Expect the front wing deflection query to go away, at least for 2024, with a possible clarification or an adjustment to the rules interpretation for 2025.chrisc90 wrote: ↑21 Jul 2024, 11:54Well its regulation that any holes are covered in the brake drum/cake tins i'd say from reading that article??FittingMechanics wrote: ↑21 Jul 2024, 11:44
Admit what?
Seems that it is a complete non factor as McLaren was very fast in Hungary.
Just my opinion.
The competitive situation is very good for business, George winning the GP the week before Silverstone filled the stands in a difficult year for the BRDC. Only my opinion but one this will go away. As the cake tin hole was summarily dismissed. I'm starting to understand why Zak is being drawn into verbal stouches with Christian Horner - he's a cheeky ba%#*&rd and it gets under people's skins. Brown has always contended that having two teams is a very precarious thing for the FIA to keep on the top of. I'd sooner we have a clean and competitive fight to the end of the season.
Thanks Chris. You're not arguing against anything I believe (and said). These things get quite pointed when you're at the sharp end of the grid. The FIA had to act and I expect they will come up with an announcement in due course - but don't hold your breath! They have a method of measurement - a static load test - which they set as their method of controlling how much the wings flex. They have every right to say "we see no reason to change the method of testing for this flex which we have been aware is happening". There's a commercial reason - when the front teams are all super competitive - for not disrupting the show. There' a technical reason also - if not a static load test, then the alternative is quite a bit more complex. On the cake tin sensor hole issue, check out Stella's full and frank comment to the TV crew on Friday - this was all rather unnecessary. Yes the potential for cheating exists (as always) but there's a valid reason for the holes, and taping them closed for qualifying and races is their simple solution. Yes, clarification is fine, but a certain two principles behave like angry bulls and for whatever reason Brown has decided to join the antagonism. I personally hate it, coming from an age where teams chip in to help another team in times of great trouble.chrisc90 wrote: ↑21 Jul 2024, 12:28Red Bull/Horner looking at what other teams are doing is exactly the same as what every other team does on the grid. Its the nature of the sport and if you are not doing things by the book, ANY team will jump on it and complain. Mercedes did it in 2022 with the floor and being hugely vocal about it, 2021 with the pit stops where nobody could get close to a Red Bull stop, multiple teams working together to work out what Ferrari were doing with their PU. Its all a big piranha tank and everyone is out to get to each other. Remember there is more than the battle on track.BMMR61 wrote: ↑21 Jul 2024, 12:15Just feel for Horner's position - the team are coming under pressure from all directions. You know when he starts insinuating others are doing illegal things, it's called "projection". They're doing stuff all the time which is "borderline" and if another team is getting the better of them , well they just must be cheating. Expect the front wing deflection query to go away, at least for 2024, with a possible clarification or an adjustment to the rules interpretation for 2025.
Just my opinion.
The competitive situation is very good for business, George winning the GP the week before Silverstone filled the stands in a difficult year for the BRDC. Only my opinion but one this will go away. As the cake tin hole was summarily dismissed. I'm starting to understand why Zak is being drawn into verbal stouches with Christian Horner - he's a cheeky ba%#*&rd and it gets under people's skins. Brown has always contended that having two teams is a very precarious thing for the FIA to keep on the top of. I'd sooner we have a clean and competitive fight to the end of the season.
RE front wing deflection..... Appreciate your opinion, but the matter was rightfully raised by a team(s) and the FIA looked into it. Clearly they have decided there is something there, or they wouldnt have spent masses amount of time and equipment/detection methods and making selected teams run cameras to determine whats going on. If there wasnt something 'serious' going on, teams would just say, "nah, we not going to run your cameras". We will see what comes of it, but at the minute, it appears to be getting a proper looking into by the FIA - quite rightfully. Its no different to the rear wing deflection tests they have put dots on the rear wing for in reality.
Cake tin holes could be quite a thing, if they are/were using additional holes to potentially warm/cool tyres up/down quicker then that could have quite an advantage come a race distance. Who knows what the advantages are on a potentially small detail like that.
I believe this is the front wind deflection tests. I was always under the impression it was done on the 2nd flap up only, but appears to be all of them; unless there is additional tests.3.15.5 Front Wing Flap Flexibility
Any part of the trailing edge of any front wing flap may deflect no more than 5mm, when measured along the loading axis, when a 60N point load is applied normal to the flap.