2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

This forum contains threads to discuss teams themselves. Anything not technical about the cars, including restructuring, performances etc belongs here.
Formula 1 fan 1996
Formula 1 fan 1996
0
Joined: 28 Aug 2024, 10:56

Re: 2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

Post

mwillems wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:49
Formula 1 fan 1996 wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:47
Is it realistic that Mclaren will fight for the driver's title in 2025?
Yes.
Which team could be main rival for McLaren for driver's title in 2025?

Lucky
Lucky
157
Joined: 15 Feb 2014, 09:23

Re: 2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

Post

Emag wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 14:43
Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 14:07
Emag wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 14:01


I have never praised Piastri either. I have given him the benefit of the doubt since this is only his second year in F1 and in Lando's second year in F1 he got outscored by Carlos. But Oscar hasn't exactly been mega-impressive when you take into consideration how many races this year he has been struggling with tire wear when Lando has had race-leading pace.

Nevertheless Lando has always been a great qualifier (generally speaking), even in his rookie season. Although this year he has been making more mistakes than usual in qualifying too.

Qualifying isn't everything though. George is destroying Lewis in their respective head-to-head. Even though people are saying this is one of the worst Lewis seasons in a while, he still is some 40 points ahead in the standings.

But the fact that Lando hasn't been able to outscore Oscar, the rookie teammate in his second year, in the last 8 or so races tells you everything.
13-3 score in qualifying, Lando is not doing well in qualifying.
241-197 race score, Lando does not race well.
The worst things about McLaren this season are strategists and management, and they are responsible for most of the blame for Norris being so far away from Max.
Ah, there is the person who looks at numbers and refuses to look past it for context.

It's not Lando who had weak Q3 last runs at Bahrain, Japan, Imola, Monaco, Silverstone and Spa.
It's not Lando who has dropped points in Saudi, Monaco, Spain, Austria, Hungary, Belgium and Italy.

Apparently being only 40 points up on your rookie teammate at his second season is considered good performance even though you only had one DNF while your teammate got f*cked in China, Miami, Imola and Silverstone through not fault of his own.
This will probably be news to Oscar fans. Lando also lost a lot of points through no fault of his own. Count carefully.

User avatar
mwillems
44
Joined: 04 Sep 2016, 22:11

Re: 2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

Post

Formula 1 fan 1996 wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:51
mwillems wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:49
Formula 1 fan 1996 wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:47
Is it realistic that Mclaren will fight for the driver's title in 2025?
Yes.
Which team could be main rival for McLaren for driver's title in 2025?
No idea. The gaps are close and any of the current top four and even Aston Martin could get in on the act.

The big backdrop to the 25 season is the 26 development.

It's why we want to be careful because some teams might sack off 25 or even some development this season so they can focus for the new regs.
I'm not taking advice from a cartoon dog

-Bandit

Emag
Emag
83
Joined: 11 Feb 2019, 14:56

Re: 2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

Post

Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:53
Emag wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 14:43
Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 14:07

13-3 score in qualifying, Lando is not doing well in qualifying.
241-197 race score, Lando does not race well.
The worst things about McLaren this season are strategists and management, and they are responsible for most of the blame for Norris being so far away from Max.
Ah, there is the person who looks at numbers and refuses to look past it for context.

It's not Lando who had weak Q3 last runs at Bahrain, Japan, Imola, Monaco, Silverstone and Spa.
It's not Lando who has dropped points in Saudi, Monaco, Spain, Austria, Hungary, Belgium and Italy.

Apparently being only 40 points up on your rookie teammate at his second season is considered good performance even though you only had one DNF while your teammate got f*cked in China, Miami, Imola and Silverstone through not fault of his own.
This will probably be news to Oscar fans. Lando also lost a lot of points through no fault of his own. Count carefully.
Okay, now I am an Oscar fan apparently. Could you be so kind and list the occasions where Lando lost points due to no fault of his own? Count carefully.

Lucky
Lucky
157
Joined: 15 Feb 2014, 09:23

Re: 2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

Post

Emag wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:56
Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:53
Emag wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 14:43


Ah, there is the person who looks at numbers and refuses to look past it for context.

It's not Lando who had weak Q3 last runs at Bahrain, Japan, Imola, Monaco, Silverstone and Spa.
It's not Lando who has dropped points in Saudi, Monaco, Spain, Austria, Hungary, Belgium and Italy.

Apparently being only 40 points up on your rookie teammate at his second season is considered good performance even though you only had one DNF while your teammate got f*cked in China, Miami, Imola and Silverstone through not fault of his own.
This will probably be news to Oscar fans. Lando also lost a lot of points through no fault of his own. Count carefully.
Okay, now I am an Oscar fan apparently. Could you be so kind and list the occasions where Lando lost points due to no fault of his own? Count carefully.
You said that, so count it, only in both directions.
Ah, there is the person who looks at numbers and refuses to look past it for context.

Emag
Emag
83
Joined: 11 Feb 2019, 14:56

Re: 2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

Post

Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:02
Emag wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:56
Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:53

This will probably be news to Oscar fans. Lando also lost a lot of points through no fault of his own. Count carefully.
Okay, now I am an Oscar fan apparently. Could you be so kind and list the occasions where Lando lost points due to no fault of his own? Count carefully.
You said that, so count it, only in both directions.
Ah, there is the person who looks at numbers and refuses to look past it for context.
I am curious to know which races you think Lando lost points through no fault of his own.

Lucky
Lucky
157
Joined: 15 Feb 2014, 09:23

Re: 2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

Post

Emag wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:06
Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:02
Emag wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:56


Okay, now I am an Oscar fan apparently. Could you be so kind and list the occasions where Lando lost points due to no fault of his own? Count carefully.
You said that, so count it, only in both directions.
Ah, there is the person who looks at numbers and refuses to look past it for context.
I am curious to know which races you think Lando lost points through no fault of his own.
At least Saudi Arabia, Australia, Canada, Austria, Britain.

Emag
Emag
83
Joined: 11 Feb 2019, 14:56

Re: 2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

Post

Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:10
Emag wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:06
Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:02

You said that, so count it, only in both directions.
I am curious to know which races you think Lando lost points through no fault of his own.
At least Saudi Arabia, Australia, Canada, Austria, Britain.
Interesting, nice talking to you then.

For other people who are open to viewing things without favoriting one driver or the other :

1 - Lando had a weak qualifying in Saudi. He got unlucky with the safety car but his pace was nothing special even compared to Oscar, so he only finished ahead of a struggling Merc and behind the driver who was racing in F1 for the first time.

2 - Although Lando claims to have had the pace to finish ahead of Leclerc in Australia, that was a comment that was made at the end of the race and he did not know the full picture. Ferrari was the better car by a decent margin and even if McLaren had reacted quicker to the undercut, he wouldn't have finished ahead of Leclerc. Not even mentioning that everyone got a free position with Max's retirement.

3 - Lando had unlucky safety car timing in Canada but McLaren fizzled out once the rain started falling again. He did not have the best pace on-track and it was Lando's decision together with the team to extend his second inters. They were even slower on full-dry and if anything, he got lucky that Russell messed up and did not overtake him because Mercedes was flying.

4 - At Austria, Lando failed to finish his overtake on Max when he had the chance during the sprint. He then got LUCKY that RedBull messed up their pitstop. Because of that. he was put into a position where he could overtake Max again, but he was hasty and ended up giving up a secure P2 at the very least.

5 - At Silverstone, the whole team messed up every single strategy choice that race but the reason I count Oscar as the one who got screwed the most is because McLaren left him out and lost him 30 seconds instead of double-stacking and losing him 5 tops.
Last edited by Emag on 07 Sep 2024, 16:27, edited 5 times in total.

User avatar
mwillems
44
Joined: 04 Sep 2016, 22:11

Re: 2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

Post

Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:10
Emag wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:06
Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:02

You said that, so count it, only in both directions.
I am curious to know which races you think Lando lost points through no fault of his own.
At least Saudi Arabia, Australia, Canada, Austria, Britain.
Austria he was gambling again putting his car i to several silly and fruitless but risky positions on track, and Britain he overshot his pit. Strategy wasn't great, but he would have come out in front of the Ferrari and brought his tyres in, instead of hitting a battle.
I'm not taking advice from a cartoon dog

-Bandit

Lucky
Lucky
157
Joined: 15 Feb 2014, 09:23

Re: 2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

Post

mwillems wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:13
Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:10
Emag wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:06


I am curious to know which races you think Lando lost points through no fault of his own.
At least Saudi Arabia, Australia, Canada, Austria, Britain.
Austria he was gambling again and Britain he overshot his pit. Strategy wasn't great, but he would have come out in front of the Ferrari and brought his tyres in, instead of hitting a battle.
Oscar fans will come up with any excuse.

Ben1980
Ben1980
1
Joined: 19 Jun 2022, 10:11

Re: 2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

Post

Formula 1 fan 1996 wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:51
mwillems wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:49
Formula 1 fan 1996 wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:47
Is it realistic that Mclaren will fight for the driver's title in 2025?
Yes.
Which team could be main rival for McLaren for driver's title in 2025?
Take your pick. I'd expect Red Bull to be favourites. Then Mclaren and Ferrari. With a Mercedes wild card, at least initially, with some spotty teen doing god knows what.

Ben1980
Ben1980
1
Joined: 19 Jun 2022, 10:11

Re: 2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

Post

Emag wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:56
Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 15:53
Emag wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 14:43


Ah, there is the person who looks at numbers and refuses to look past it for context.

It's not Lando who had weak Q3 last runs at Bahrain, Japan, Imola, Monaco, Silverstone and Spa.
It's not Lando who has dropped points in Saudi, Monaco, Spain, Austria, Hungary, Belgium and Italy.

Apparently being only 40 points up on your rookie teammate at his second season is considered good performance even though you only had one DNF while your teammate got f*cked in China, Miami, Imola and Silverstone through not fault of his own.
This will probably be news to Oscar fans. Lando also lost a lot of points through no fault of his own. Count carefully.
Okay, now I am an Oscar fan apparently. Could you be so kind and list the occasions where Lando lost points due to no fault of his own? Count carefully.
I can give you Miami when Sainz took him out. Silverstone definitely when the team didn't double stack. Where was the place ge had a 3 place penalty, though not sure if that was on him, the team or both.

Ben1980
Ben1980
1
Joined: 19 Jun 2022, 10:11

Re: 2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

Post

mwillems wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:13
Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:10
Emag wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:06


I am curious to know which races you think Lando lost points through no fault of his own.
At least Saudi Arabia, Australia, Canada, Austria, Britain.
Austria he was gambling again putting his car i to several silly and fruitless but risky positions on track, and Britain he overshot his pit. Strategy wasn't great, but he would have come out in front of the Ferrari and brought his tyres in, instead of hitting a battle.
With the soft performance im not sure he would have held on anyway. The strategy was the decider on that one.

He came out 2 behind Hamilton, and had a 4.5 pit, ( from memory) so it was always going to be a fight.

User avatar
mwillems
44
Joined: 04 Sep 2016, 22:11

Re: 2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

Post

Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:15
mwillems wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:13
Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:10

At least Saudi Arabia, Australia, Canada, Austria, Britain.
Austria he was gambling again and Britain he overshot his pit. Strategy wasn't great, but he would have come out in front of the Ferrari and brought his tyres in, instead of hitting a battle.
Oscar fans will come up with any excuse.
So these weren't key reasons for his final classification? It's no point that he came close to getting around Max on 2 occasions in Austria Throw the car alongside like that against Max and you know what will happen, do it 20 times and you should expect it. He was a desperate gambler again.

Silverstone was one of those things. His mistake put him in a position where he cooked his tyres. Strategy was the bigger problem, but to suggest Lando didn't screw up is somewhere between optimism and denial.
I'm not taking advice from a cartoon dog

-Bandit

User avatar
mwillems
44
Joined: 04 Sep 2016, 22:11

Re: 2024 Mclaren Formula 1 Team

Post

Ben1980 wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:21
mwillems wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:13
Lucky wrote:
07 Sep 2024, 16:10

At least Saudi Arabia, Australia, Canada, Austria, Britain.
Austria he was gambling again putting his car i to several silly and fruitless but risky positions on track, and Britain he overshot his pit. Strategy wasn't great, but he would have come out in front of the Ferrari and brought his tyres in, instead of hitting a battle.
With the soft performance im not sure he would have held on anyway. The strategy was the decider on that one.

He came out 2 behind Hamilton, and had a 4.5 pit, ( from memory) so it was always going to be a fight.
He didn't get the chance to see. He screwed over the dodgy strategy and let Max finish ahead of him as a direct result.
I'm not taking advice from a cartoon dog

-Bandit