Seanspeed wrote: ↑05 Mar 2025, 01:09
Bill wrote: ↑04 Mar 2025, 09:44
the difference between a quick and worst driver in f1 is 0.3 tenth according to engineers ,when redbull car was driverable perez was capable of matching or beating Max so its not funny that Tsunoda can beat Max on odd races he has proven to be quick driver and can handle difficult cars.he put his car p3 in brazil quali beating rainmaster max.so my question has not been answered why is it difficult for second driver to extract pace on that Rb
First you admit that Perez was capable of being competitive against Max. But the whole argument was supposed to be that Red Bull *dont* want somebody who is competitive against him.
So why did they hire and keep Perez when he was considered capable and competitive? And if they wanted some worthless scrub as a teammate, why did they get rid of Perez when he was no longer competitive?
Doesn't make any sense.
Sorry to jump in, but i think you miss the reasons:
1. Help with bringing home the constructors championship.
2. Never make Max unhappy ie. don't beat him consistently.
Notice the direct instructions to Lawson: paraphrasing - "NEVER challenge Max. Just score points".
Max has always had one of the weakest 2nd driver lineup on the grid for his entire career. He's never been challenged that much. He now expects that environment if he is to stay happy. We saw it several times last year. When Max gets challenged on track by other drivers he starts buckling and getting on the radio complaining about some phantom issue. Other drivers and principals said the same thing. Now can u imagine if that was happening with a strong second driver at RB? OMG. Nursery school all over again.
Objectively, we all agree that RBR will never allow Hamilton, Alonso, Leclerc, Sainz, Russell, or in this case, a Tsunoda to be the other driver with Max. It ain't gonna happen. Just facts. Note that i did not include Norris. Norris is still weak-minded and gets afraid by his own shadow despite his talent. He might be better this year, finally. The #1 reason is because the ones i mentioned WILL make max VERY unhappy because lets face it, they WILL beat Max many times -- both will be robbing points off each other. They relish the challenge.
Perez beating Max on occasion will happen from time to time, only when the car is not biased in favor of Max, which it has been as each season's upgrades come in, but the key thing was the hope Perez would help them bring stability for their Constructor hopes. In equal, stable machinery where the upgrades aren't directly biased to help Max only, then yes, Perez could definitely compete against Max -- we usually see it at the beginning of a season -- BUT that is not how RBR operates. Never has. Their driving styles are very different. As the upgrades come in, they know Perez will get weaker and they dont care because its all about keeping Max happy -- as long as Perez can bring in the points for the Constructors. RBR finally admits that they should have listened to Perez, that the car was becoming unstable. He can compete against Max but he is no Alpha driver like the ones i mentioned. The ones i mentioned would soon make Max question why he is in F1. And as such, is why RB would never allow that to happen. Never. So when Sainz was in talks with RBR, it was very obvious he had no shot. None! It wasnt because of some long-dead feud with Sainz Sr. and Jos..that's just naive and stupid to think that. Tsunoda, same issue.
Lawson is a question mark for RBR. They believe he can bring in the points for the Constructors, but they are hoping because he is a rookie and with a stern warning not to challenge Max, that he will obey like the other weak 2nd drivers they've had. I'm sure Lawson will initially obey, but once his confidence grows i wonder if his ambition will look to challenge and beat Max. And then the nightmare scenario for RB: Max becoming upset due to it.
I recall Hamilton in his rookie season. His performance is regarded almost unanimously as the greatest rookie season ever. He was even poised to win the Drivers Championship with relative ease despite Fernando Alonso, the current reining Champion, as his partner. Insanely strong lineup. Although Hamilton was considered an prodigy, McLaren was not expecting he'd be even more gifted than they thought -- an even bigger Alpha than Alonso. It broke Alonso mentally and he's been bitter ever since. Hence, RBR is traumatized by a similar situation happening with Max. So, protect Max at all costs is their motto -- nurse and nurture their baby.
And that strategy has been working very well for them for years!
