2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post here all non technical related topics about Formula One. This includes race results, discussions, testing analysis etc. TV coverage and other personal questions should be in Off topic chat.
aterren
aterren
1
Joined: 13 Jul 2009, 05:31

2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post

Perez was Ferrari academy driver....could his move to McLaren be in anyway tied to a deal for McLaren to use Ferrari engines in 2014? Maybe a bit far fetched given their rivalry, secret stealing past, etc but here are some things to consider:

Could Hamilton move mean be an indicator that Merc does not want to supply McLaren? Big open question for McLaren at this point.

wesley123
wesley123
204
Joined: 23 Feb 2008, 17:55

Re: 2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post

I dont think anyone has to answer that question. A Ferrari engine in the back of the mac will NEVER happen.
"Bite my shiny metal ass" - Bender

Nando
Nando
2
Joined: 10 Mar 2012, 02:30

Re: 2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post

"When pigs fly" has never been a more fitting quote.
"Il Phenomeno" - The one they fear the most!

"2% of the world's population own 50% of the world's wealth."

JimClarkFan
JimClarkFan
27
Joined: 18 Mar 2012, 23:31

Re: 2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post

wesley123 wrote:I dont think anyone has to answer that question. A Ferrari engine in the back of the mac will NEVER happen.
pretty much, arch rivals

User avatar
WhiteBlue
92
Joined: 14 Apr 2008, 20:58
Location: WhiteBlue Country

Re: 2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post

What a strange thread for a technical forum.
Formula One's fundamental ethos is about success coming to those with the most ingenious engineering and best .............................. organization, not to those with the biggest budget. (Dave Richards)

CHT
CHT
-6
Joined: 14 Apr 2008, 05:24

Re: 2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post

I actually think its a matter of time that Mclaren will design their own engine.

wunderkind
wunderkind
5
Joined: 04 Apr 2007, 06:12

Re: 2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post

CHT wrote:I actually think its a matter of time that Mclaren will design their own engine.
2014 will see a Slim-powered Telmex McLaren :D :D :D

The engine will be run on an endless supply of USD.

wunderkind
wunderkind
5
Joined: 04 Apr 2007, 06:12

Re: 2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post

Seriously though, McLaren would be mad not to keep their Mercedes engines given the recent overtures from Bernie and LdM that they do not like the aural qualities of the 2014 V6 engines and would like to keep the V8 engines for a few more years.

I interpret that as Ferrari is struggling with the new engine design............

marcush.
marcush.
159
Joined: 09 Mar 2004, 16:55

Re: 2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post

Mclaren is a OEM these days and they are spitting in the garden of BMW,VW,Mercedes to name a few.Yes -it´s not uncommon to see Mercedes engines in Nissans and Renault engines in Mercedes but don´t you think it creates more chaos to
actually run a commercial competitors engine to build your own fame ?
Ultimately Mclaren needs to build their own powertrain -simply because they already do this with their roadcars.They need to prove they are the experts in every area -and powertrain is a key field of expertise.
Just look up the Mclaren electronics website and it is blatantly clear they are commited to go the WHOLE route.They have their own development tools in place -comparable to INCA (ETAS) which is used in the rest of the world -a ver unique situation unmatched by DAimler ,VW or BMW methinks..
Mclaren may be the single team actually feeding racetechnology back into commercial car production - a clever move to lure potnetial customers to buy a Mclaren.

wunderkind
wunderkind
5
Joined: 04 Apr 2007, 06:12

Re: 2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post

marcush. wrote:Mclaren is a OEM these days and they are spitting in the garden of BMW,VW,Mercedes to name a few.Yes -it´s not uncommon to see Mercedes engines in Nissans and Renault engines in Mercedes but don´t you think it creates more chaos to
actually run a commercial competitors engine to build your own fame ?
Ultimately Mclaren needs to build their own powertrain -simply because they already do this with their roadcars.They need to prove they are the experts in every area -and powertrain is a key field of expertise.
Just look up the Mclaren electronics website and it is blatantly clear they are commited to go the WHOLE route.They have their own development tools in place -comparable to INCA (ETAS) which is used in the rest of the world -a ver unique situation unmatched by DAimler ,VW or BMW methinks..
Mclaren may be the single team actually feeding racetechnology back into commercial car production - a clever move to lure potnetial customers to buy a Mclaren.
It all depends on whether they can secure long term funding to finance such a risky undertaking. McLaren would need upwards of $150million to fund the start of a competitive engine program and at least half that amount annually to keep up with the top engine manufacturers. Where is the money going to come from? The capital markets are closed to McLaren and new sources of private funding are unfeasible. That leaves Señor Slim I guess. But it will have to be a multiple year commitment. As Roger Penske famously said, "only go racing with other people's money".

As for VW becoming an engine supplier...........doubtful. The only way to do it is to acquire Cosworth's F1 engine operations (VW bought Cosworth's engineering business a few years ago), or acquire the remnants of the PURE business. A long shot will be for Dr. Piech to assemble the talents at Audi racing and Porsche racing to start from scratch.

BMW, forget them. No one in the upper echelon of BMW has any desire to race in F1.

Raptor22
Raptor22
26
Joined: 07 Apr 2009, 22:48

Re: 2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post

marcush. wrote:Mclaren is a OEM these days and they are spitting in the garden of BMW,VW,Mercedes to name a few.Yes -it´s not uncommon to see Mercedes engines in Nissans and Renault engines in Mercedes but don´t you think it creates more chaos to
actually run a commercial competitors engine to build your own fame ?
Ultimately Mclaren needs to build their own powertrain -simply because they already do this with their roadcars.They need to prove they are the experts in every area -and powertrain is a key field of expertise.
Just look up the Mclaren electronics website and it is blatantly clear they are commited to go the WHOLE route.They have their own development tools in place -comparable to INCA (ETAS) which is used in the rest of the world -a ver unique situation unmatched by DAimler ,VW or BMW methinks..
Mclaren may be the single team actually feeding racetechnology back into commercial car production - a clever move to lure potnetial customers to buy a Mclaren.

Yeah I agree. Hamilton's desire to move is more indicative of the potential for McLaren to NOT have a Mercedes engine in 2014.
However Bernie is claiming to try and kill the 2014 engine regs. If that happens McLaren won't be building their own engine I fear.
The new regs actually favour smaller engine manufacturers because of lot of the expertise can be bought from current OEM's and consultants like Ricardo. Its a simpler package, even if it may cost more upfront, the cost benefit will only be realised by season 2015 or 2016 and by then it will be attracting a lot more than just Mercedes, Ferrari and Renault.
McLaren's decision to build their own engine will have a lot do with a decision to retain or can the new engines.

Raptor22
Raptor22
26
Joined: 07 Apr 2009, 22:48

Re: 2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post

wunderkind wrote:
marcush. wrote:Mclaren is a OEM these days and they are spitting in the garden of BMW,VW,Mercedes to name a few.Yes -it´s not uncommon to see Mercedes engines in Nissans and Renault engines in Mercedes but don´t you think it creates more chaos to
actually run a commercial competitors engine to build your own fame ?
Ultimately Mclaren needs to build their own powertrain -simply because they already do this with their roadcars.They need to prove they are the experts in every area -and powertrain is a key field of expertise.
Just look up the Mclaren electronics website and it is blatantly clear they are commited to go the WHOLE route.They have their own development tools in place -comparable to INCA (ETAS) which is used in the rest of the world -a ver unique situation unmatched by DAimler ,VW or BMW methinks..
Mclaren may be the single team actually feeding racetechnology back into commercial car production - a clever move to lure potnetial customers to buy a Mclaren.
It all depends on whether they can secure long term funding to finance such a risky undertaking. McLaren would need upwards of $150million to fund the start of a competitive engine program and at least half that amount annually to keep up with the top engine manufacturers. Where is the money going to come from? The capital markets are closed to McLaren and new sources of private funding are unfeasible. That leaves Señor Slim I guess. But it will have to be a multiple year commitment. As Roger Penske famously said, "only go racing with other people's money".

As for VW becoming an engine supplier...........doubtful. The only way to do it is to acquire Cosworth's F1 engine operations (VW bought Cosworth's engineering business a few years ago), or acquire the remnants of the PURE business. A long shot will be for Dr. Piech to assemble the talents at Audi racing and Porsche racing to start from scratch.

BMW, forget them. No one in the upper echelon of BMW has any desire to race in F1.

Cosworths F1 engine operation has no experience in the new engine formula whereas the Engineering operation does...
Vw is a definate possibility BUT they are fully committed to WRC for 2013 and Sports Car Endurance racing with the Audi brand. If they enter F1 as engine supplier it will likely only be after a few years of the new formula once they can fully understand the business model for such an engine. $150million to develop the engine...? possibly but thats less than the cost of a new factory and much less than the cost of development of Golf VII. They are possibly the worlds leading company wrt development of small displacement turbo charged eco engines so I'm pretty sure they can do if for less and they can spread supply contracts across quite a few brands.

Nando
Nando
2
Joined: 10 Mar 2012, 02:30

Re: 2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post

wunderkind wrote:BMW, forget them. No one in the upper echelon of BMW has any desire to race in F1.
Building engines is a completely different thing though. And with Mclaren as partner instead of Williams it might be a lucrative deal.

However i think the very tight regulations is something BMW despise. Give them free:er regs and they will create magic.
"Il Phenomeno" - The one they fear the most!

"2% of the world's population own 50% of the world's wealth."

Raptor22
Raptor22
26
Joined: 07 Apr 2009, 22:48

Re: 2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post

its not the tight regs but rather the rules around engine homologation that keeps BMW and Cosworth out. Cosworth realised that they had a potent engine but to get reliability they needed to be able to develop the engine in the first season. Thats not allowed hence we have three engine suppliers in F1 now.

Nando
Nando
2
Joined: 10 Mar 2012, 02:30

Re: 2014 - McLaren Engine - Is Perez and Indication?

Post

Raptor22 wrote:its not the tight regs but rather the rules around engine homologation that keeps BMW and Cosworth out. Cosworth realised that they had a potent engine but to get reliability they needed to be able to develop the engine in the first season. Thats not allowed hence we have three engine suppliers in F1 now.
Pretty sure it´s also these things,

Fixed litres,
Fixed angle,
single turbocharger along centerline
fixed fuel flow

Pretty sure there´s a fixed CoG and fixed weight as well.

No innovation whatsoever. Instead of letting engine manufacturers let loose a little bit more.
Just like aerodynamics. we don´t have fixed standard wings, fixed angle of attack, fixed this fixed that.
Sure we have regulations saying where you can put wings but that´s about as far as it goes.
"Il Phenomeno" - The one they fear the most!

"2% of the world's population own 50% of the world's wealth."