MikeMargarido wrote:In any event, IMO there are few global truths when it comes to race tires - or tires in general. Lot of BS that makes its way around, gets repeated enough times and people believe it's a universal truth. Generally I find those who are blatantly the most outspoken with "this is how it is" tend to be the most full of it.
I'm new here, though I have been following these forums for years. It has frequently provided good reads on tires and vehicle dynamics.
From what I have seen through the years, what you say above applies perfectly to you - in particular in regards to tire models (ISIMotor2, iRacing).
I fully agree with you, though. The most adamant, self-assured individuals usually have no regard for the opinions of others; I have found they're little more than inflated balloons.
You'd have to elaborate as I don't follow to some degree, not sure whether or not you're insulting me, agreeing with me, or both!
In any event, people working in racing or other high performance "on the edge" fields can certainly be quite blunt, adamant, pointed, or self assured. Attracts some Type A personalities, and when you've "seen something with your own eyes" and feel confident in it, well - how can one argue with results? But there is a fine line between "X is the [only] solution" and "X has always worked for me in situation Y, here's how and why I think it pertains to situation Z." Or even more so, there's a big difference between passing along your
own individual experience, and regurgitating the experience or comments of others in different situations. The latter drives me nuts.
MikeMargarido wrote:Raw Data wrote:
This class runs on a treaded tire that is allowed to be cut. I always thought with my ME degree maybe I could help him in some way. Boy was I wrong. He is a high school drop out, has never read any racing books. But he has so much experience with these cars and tires it is just priceless.
He knows one thing. Trial and Error. He has a very large notebook. It has gotten him very far.
Trial and Error will only carry you so far - simply not possible to have tested all compounds, all types of tires on all types of cars. Intuition (or some form of extrapolation) does not work always, does not yield positive results the whole time.
As things become more complex, true knowledge (always a result of books + research + life experience) is irreplaceable and turns out to be the deciding factor in success. In particular in motorsports.
I would agree with Lycoming that trial and error, aka build and test or whatever you want to call it, can get you quite far. Sometimes it's the only thing that can get you anywhere. Books and publications... in find that there are few which are cutting edge, particularly in racing. People and companies like to hold onto their IP and competitive advantage. "High level" research, you may or may not have the resources to pursue. But you can
always go out and try to learn something when you turn laps.
Grip is a four letter word. All opinions are my own and not those of current or previous employers.