AnthonyG wrote:Lopez is by no means without mistakes, but on the other hand:
Lopez is so bad at managing a team it made a car that is often envied by many other teams with better financials.
Lopez is a smart man to invest in infrastructure, R&D always gets carried over.
Investing in F1 teams is a horrible business and very complex, it's easy to point the finger at one man.
These were not some minor mistakes, these were huge mistakes in terms of
- driver choices including financial side with consequences, running F1 team is about choices where and when to spend your money, they were losing engineers left, right and center and pretended it wasn't a problem, look at Williams as an example of not making those mistakes and benefiting from it. Plus driver policies, including ridiculous amount of team orders and unprecedented "one driver exists" approach - whole 2013 wasted. Team was run in an unhealthy manner and it transfers to other areas.
- not finding replacement for technical and managerial staff they lost, you may lose Allison or Boullier but you need hire someone instead and have a plan for the future doing that. Overlapping period when you prepare the replacement not improvisation mid-season. That's what Force India used to do - they lost big names and got better. Alternatively hire someone from outside: Symonds was available - look where Williams is now. Key was available - now look at Toro Rosso.
All of it resulted in sporting and financial loses, bad preparation for huge changes of '14, sponsors leaving, many engineers leaving and current state of this team, these are the real world consequences. We're talking about a team that:
- didn't want to win a GP on merit in Germany just because of idiotic policy
- in this very season sold a dozen of FP sessions almost getting rid of one of the last remaining competitive advantages and claimed it was not a problem affecting performance. On top of that knowing it costs them they tried to divide these sessions between two drivers and when Maldonado refused they turned publicly against him. They blamed the other driver instead of themselves. One podium doesn't change stupidity of this approach which they were planning to repeat next season.
- got rid off of a large amount of engineers 5 minutes before the season of the biggest technical changes in decades later to admit it was a mistake,
- sacrificed reliability for performance in 2015 and achieved neither (starting with gearboxes) on top of all kinds of operational mistakes.
- to summarize: in 2012 didn't need money, 2013 - results, 2014 - engineers, 2015 - drivers
As for Renault supposedly buying part of the team and letting the current owner manage it it's their money and problem but it looks like it was done for financial reasons (amounts mentioned are not big) - F1 on the cheap - which I guess didn't work that great on the engine side. Currently Lopez is a part time TP with four others: Carter, Chester, Permane, Gastaldi running their bits and pieces and the whole team is a mess.