how about no!
the renault livery indeed is exciting, the thing with the macca liveries why people cling back much to the old livery is not just because of the livery, but because of what it meant. it was at one of the best moments of time in F1, Senna, dominant mclaren-honda. these liveries bring that feeling of excitement back.
if Mclaren actually would be battling for the championship, i'm sure the comment on the liveries would be much less.
and, lets face it, their liveries haven't been really enjoyable the past couple of years.
btw, is that you in the avatar????