zeus2 wrote: ↑31 Jul 2017, 00:46
Phil wrote: ↑31 Jul 2017, 00:08
zeus2 wrote: ↑30 Jul 2017, 23:29
Finally, well said. I was sitting back, flabbergasted, thinking "wait a minute, are people actually complaining about ferrari not issuing team orders, but happy with mercs doing so?
So it's a team-order when a team openly tells both their drivers to swap positions, but it's not a "team-order" when a team is doing everything possible to protect their one driver in the lead from their 2nd driver who is evidently faster from passing him?
AMuS already has the analysis that to pit Kimi a lap after Vettel was bad, as Kimi had a lot of pace on that tire and had he stayed out just a lap longer, might have actually gotten ahead of Vettel. Kimi even came on the radio after the pitstop questioning the timing of that stop, as he didn't understand it, even if it was quite evident to the rest of the world as to what was going on...
http://www.auto-motor-und-sport.de/form ... 97159.html
Agree with you about the potential bottas and hamilton battle. As far as team orders are concerned, Kimi never asked to be let through as he himself specifically pointed out in the interview with sky when the reporter tried to sneakily suggest that he did. So if kimi didn't ask to be let through, then it would have been team orders if ferrari ordered seb to let him through, which they didn't. As for bringing kimi in when they did, kimi did 1.23.7 on his in lap and a 1.22.7 on the lap prior to his in lap (the lap seb pitted), while the mercs were doing high 1.21's and low 1.22's on their fresh rubber, so you can understand why ferrari were concerned and pitted him, afterall they were racing the mercs first. Kimi pretty much acknowledged that the team had the bigger picture and accepted it later in his ferrari post race comments.
Look at this:
Lap26 VET 1:22.386 -> RAI 1:22.442 -> BOT -> 1:22.632
Lap27 VET 1:22.550 -> RAI 1:22.509 -> BOT -> 1:22.675
Lap28 VET 1:23.079 -> RAI 1:22.675 -> BOT -> 1:22.439
Lap29 VET 1:23.447 -> RAI 1:23.157 -> BOT -> 1:22.791
Lap30 VET 1:22.592 -> RAI 1:22.744 -> BOT -> 1:25.008P (<-- BOT pit, was 7.487s behind VET, 6.292s behind RAI)
Lap31
VET 1:23.665 ->
RAI 1:23.733 -> BOT -> 1:41.001O (<-- BOT pit and outlap, VET -> RAI gap at 1.415s)
Lap32
VET 1:25.390P ->
RAI 1:22.701 -> BOT -> 1:21.656 (<-- VET pit)
Lap33
VET 1:39.996O ->
RAI 1:23.778P -> BOT -> 1:21.264 (<-- RAI pit)
Lap34 VET 1:21.993 -> RAI 1:40.609O -> BOT -> 1:22.149
Lap35 VET 1:22.785 -> RAI 1:22.839 -> BOT -> 1:22.367
Lap36 VET 1:23.090 -> RAI 1:23.352 -> BOT -> 1:22.566
Lap37 VET 1:22.483 -> RAI 1:22.832 -> BOT -> 1:23.071
I didn't include the gaps between VET and RAI, but for all intends and purpose, it was hovering between 1.0 and 1.5s after Lap28. The gap from RAI to BOT was at the point of him pitting at 6.292s.
Vettel last complete lap before pitting was a 1:23.665. Then on Lap32, Vettel pitted with a time of 1:25.390. That very same lap, Kimi was released within that last stretch of that lap and completed that same lap with a 1:22.701 (9 tenths faster than Vettel on his previous lap).
Lap33, Vettel is inside the pits and drives out plus has his outlap and completed all that within a 1:39.996. That same lap, RAI was called into the pits, his IN-LAP being a 1:23.778. That was more than 1.5s faster than what Vettel did on his. I don't have the sector times, but I'm fairly confident the sector times were lit up like a christmas tree.
Then Lap34, we see that RAI has a less sufficient outlap of 1:40.609 but this is easily explained by Kimi coming out the pits and straight into Vettels rear bumper at a distance of 1.1s behind him, so this time is moot and not relevant.
Also relevant - the gap between RAI and BOT.
Lap31 - it was 25.824s.
Lap32 - it was 24.779s.
Lap33 - it was 22.265s (though this one is slightly off, due to Kimi being slowed by his pit-entry)
Also relevant: When Vettel pitted lap32 and came out lap33, his gap to Kimi was 17.492s. So I'd estimate the "cost" of pitting to be around 18 seconds.
In other words - Kimi's performance once released by Vettel and the lap he was called in to pit were amazing laps and there was more than a sufficient gap to the Mercedes to keep him out longer,
if the team had acted in his interest.
Now you tell me with a straight face that Ferrari was NOT protecting Vettels lead at any cost? How could it be any different, considering Vettel was driving a handicapped car for 3/4 of the entire race and wasn't passed by the faster driver, his team-mate?
I'm happy to concede that once Vettel had pitted, the off-set of the fresher tire might have worked in Vettels favor even if Kimi had stayed out a lap longer, but man, you gotta wonder how close it could have been. There was no immediate risk from behind at that point, if the team had genuinely given Kimi a fair shot at it.