Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post here all non technical related topics about Formula One. This includes race results, discussions, testing analysis etc. TV coverage and other personal questions should be in Off topic chat.
bonjon1979
bonjon1979
30
Joined: 11 Feb 2009, 17:16

Re: Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post

CBeck113 wrote:
06 Apr 2018, 08:23
That decision led to 4 titles - I wouldn't call it a bad decision...
Exactly. What I'm saying is that we need to take Horner's whinging with a pinch of salt as all he's trying to do is improve their position.

User avatar
Andres125sx
166
Joined: 13 Aug 2013, 10:15
Location: Madrid, Spain

Re: Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post

Wich doesn´t change the fact FIA usually change rules to stop anyone domination after 4 seasons. They did in RBR era, but didn´t in current one so Mercedes domination will probably last 6 seasons, more than any other

foxmulder_ms
foxmulder_ms
1
Joined: 10 Feb 2011, 20:36

Re: Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post

Did Horner ask for the ban of the "white smoke" from Ferrari yet??? haha

User avatar
Big Tea
99
Joined: 24 Dec 2017, 20:57

Re: Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post

foxmulder_ms wrote:
07 Apr 2018, 21:00
Did Horner ask for the ban of the "white smoke" from Ferrari yet??? haha
I thought that meant they had agreed on a new pontiff?
When arguing with a fool, be sure the other person is not doing the same thing.

DarkSurferZA
DarkSurferZA
0
Joined: 11 Mar 2017, 07:53

Re: Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post

strad wrote:I'm inclined to disagree with Horner on the one hand but on the other how far away is this from having special hand grenade qualifying engines which were banned some time ago?
I for one miss the old qualy engines. That was cut to reduce cost, so I accept the rule change even if I don't like it. The software mode is very different. Has no effect on cost.

It's about managing the car through the weekend. What is next, ban fuel saving mid race? That's an engine mode, right?

Sent from my SM-T815 using Tapatalk


Brenton
Brenton
1
Joined: 17 Dec 2017, 07:28

Re: Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post

DarkSurferZA wrote:
07 Apr 2018, 23:29
strad wrote:I'm inclined to disagree with Horner on the one hand but on the other how far away is this from having special hand grenade qualifying engines which were banned some time ago?
I for one miss the old qualy engines. That was cut to reduce cost, so I accept the rule change even if I don't like it. The software mode is very different. Has no effect on cost.

It's about managing the car through the weekend. What is next, ban fuel saving mid race? That's an engine mode, right?

Sent from my SM-T815 using Tapatalk
Engines being designed to run on various significantly different maps, and designing the maps themselves probably adds millions to development costs. Okay, maybe just a million or two?

DarkSurferZA
DarkSurferZA
0
Joined: 11 Mar 2017, 07:53

Re: Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post

Brenton wrote:
DarkSurferZA wrote:
07 Apr 2018, 23:29
strad wrote:I'm inclined to disagree with Horner on the one hand but on the other how far away is this from having special hand grenade qualifying engines which were banned some time ago?
I for one miss the old qualy engines. That was cut to reduce cost, so I accept the rule change even if I don't like it. The software mode is very different. Has no effect on cost.

It's about managing the car through the weekend. What is next, ban fuel saving mid race? That's an engine mode, right?

Sent from my SM-T815 using Tapatalk
Engines being designed to run on various significantly different maps, and designing the maps themselves probably adds millions to development costs. Okay, maybe just a million or two?
So ban wet race modes, and fuel saving modes, and diff settings, also Strat 7 mix 3 etc etc... Everything costs money, but at the risk of becoming a kart race series , there are some things that are just rediculous to tamper with. All teams have paid for engine mode software configs, but Merc have a better hardware package and are therefore able to unlock hardware potential using software.

If you give the Renault guys the Merc party mode config, I am sure their hardware will just go poof.

Horner was happy to have ebd but gets all touchy when it's something they don't have. About time we see past the playground antics and stop giving the cry babies (they have them in all the teams) more air time than they deserve

Sent from my SM-T815 using Tapatalk


Gaz.
Gaz.
4
Joined: 24 Jul 2010, 09:53

Re: Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post

Results by engine:

Australia qualifying:

1st - Mercdes
2nd- Ferrari
3rd- Ferrari
4th- Renault
5th- Renault
6th- Ferrari
7th- Ferrari
8th- Renault
9th- Renault
10th- Mercedes
11th-Renault
12th-Renault
13th-Mercedes
14th-Mercedes
15th-Mercedes
16th-Honda
17th-Ferrari
18th-Ferrari
19th-Mercedes
20th-Honda

Race:

1st - Ferrari
2nd- Mercedes
3rd - Ferrari
4th - Renault
5th - Renault
6th - Renault
7th- Renault
8th- Mercedes
9th- Renault
10th- Renault
11th- Mercedes
12th-Mercedes
13th- Ferrari
14th- Mercedes
15th- Honda

Bahrain Qualli:

1st- Ferrari
2nd- Ferrari
3rd- Mercedes
4th -Renault
5th- Mercedes
6th- Honda
7th- Ferrari
8th- Renault
9th- Mercedes
10th- Renault
11th- Honda
12th - Mercedes
13th- Renault
14th- Renault
15th- Renault
16th- Ferrari
17th- Ferrari
18th- Mercedes
19th- Ferrari
20th- Mercedes

Race:

1st- Ferrari
2nd- Mercedes
3rd- Mercedes
4th- Honda
5th- Ferrari
6th- Renault
7th- Renault
8th- Renault
9th- Ferrari
10th- Mercedes
11th- Renault
12th- Ferrari
13th- Ferrari
14th- Mercedes
15th- Mercedes
16th- Mercedes
17th- Honda

If each stable scored points:

1st -Ferrari - 72pts
2nd- Renault - 57pts
3rd- Mercedes- 56pts
4th- Honda- 12pts.

That looks pretty even to me.
Forza Jules

Brenton
Brenton
1
Joined: 17 Dec 2017, 07:28

Re: Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post

DarkSurferZA wrote:
09 Apr 2018, 14:35
Brenton wrote:
DarkSurferZA wrote:
07 Apr 2018, 23:29
I for one miss the old qualy engines. That was cut to reduce cost, so I accept the rule change even if I don't like it. The software mode is very different. Has no effect on cost.

It's about managing the car through the weekend. What is next, ban fuel saving mid race? That's an engine mode, right?

Sent from my SM-T815 using Tapatalk
Engines being designed to run on various significantly different maps, and designing the maps themselves probably adds millions to development costs. Okay, maybe just a million or two?
So ban wet race modes, and fuel saving modes, and diff settings, also Strat 7 mix 3 etc etc... Everything costs money, but at the risk of becoming a kart race series , there are some things that are just rediculous to tamper with. All teams have paid for engine mode software configs, but Merc have a better hardware package and are therefore able to unlock hardware potential using software.

If you give the Renault guys the Merc party mode config, I am sure their hardware will just go poof.

Horner was happy to have ebd but gets all touchy when it's something they don't have. About time we see past the playground antics and stop giving the cry babies (they have them in all the teams) more air time than they deserve

Sent from my SM-T815 using Tapatalk
Banning multiple modes isn't going to turn F1 into a spec series. Multiple modes isn't even in the essence of racing as most people know it. It's totally unnecessary and costly. People know and like racing in what I see as it's pure concepts of having a car that performs a similar hp each lap, leaving it up to the driver, fuel load (weight), and tire selection and tire wear determining what the car can do. Not performance determined by what map was chosen in that moment.

It's like if a battery could be charged over multiple laps to give a big boost for a qualifying lap. It's not allowed for good reason, and instead there's a limit for the amount of electricity used per lap to keep the output per lap fairly equal.

CBeck113
CBeck113
51
Joined: 17 Feb 2013, 19:43

Re: Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post

I am not a fan of the reasoning behind CH's call for the ban, but I am all for banning them. Liberty wants more DNFs due to failures, and we fans want to see racing, so let the drivers control the motor with their foot only. The teams couldn't afford the risk of detuning their engine, because there are other teams like McLaren, Renault, FI or Haas would risk destroying an engine to get a win. THAT would spice things up :-)
“Strange women lying in ponds distributing swords is no basis for a system of government. Supreme executive power derives from a mandate from the masses, not from some farcical aquatic ceremony!” Monty Python and the Holy Grail

User avatar
Cuky
65
Joined: 07 Dec 2011, 19:41
Location: Rab, Croatia

Re: Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post

Andres125sx wrote:
06 Apr 2018, 13:54
Wich doesn´t change the fact FIA usually change rules to stop anyone domination after 4 seasons. They did in RBR era, but didn´t in current one so Mercedes domination will probably last 6 seasons, more than any other
Rules were changed, massively, for 2017... and Mercedes, sadly, still came on top

User avatar
Andres125sx
166
Joined: 13 Aug 2013, 10:15
Location: Madrid, Spain

Re: Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post

Aero rules were changed, on an era we all know it´s the PU wich makes the difference ;)

User avatar
Cuky
65
Joined: 07 Dec 2011, 19:41
Location: Rab, Croatia

Re: Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post

True. But there was a possibility that Mercedes will get something wrong and that their PU won't be able to do much with a flawed car. They probably did get something a bit wrong last year because Ferrari came close to them, but they still did good enough job to stay on top

User avatar
Big Tea
99
Joined: 24 Dec 2017, 20:57

Re: Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post

So when 'back in the old days' ( #-o ) the driver and mechanic had an air lever and a spark advance lever and even manual control of the amount of oil burned to a degree, was this considered 'engine modes'?

That is all the system does in effect, but with 'presets' equivalent to a notch on the bezel.
When arguing with a fool, be sure the other person is not doing the same thing.

Gaz.
Gaz.
4
Joined: 24 Jul 2010, 09:53

Re: Horner: Qualy modes should be banned!

Post

Andres125sx wrote:
10 Apr 2018, 09:30
Aero rules were changed, on an era we all know it´s the PU wich makes the difference ;)
So what happened to Williams then?
Forza Jules