German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

For ease of use, there is one thread per grand prix where you can discuss everything during that specific GP weekend. You can find these threads here.
User avatar
ISLAMATRON
0
Joined: 01 Oct 2008, 18:29

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

paused wrote:IMO the move with Rubens was a bit too aggresive. He really only need to squeeze him rather than belt him but then again probabky no worse that at least 10 moves from Lewis in 07/08.
List out those 10 times when Lewis hit anyone... exactly... bullshit.

RacingManiac
RacingManiac
9
Joined: 22 Nov 2004, 02:29

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

Good win by Mark, he was absolutely dominant and very lucky as well(thanks to stewards' slow decision he actually ran to Rubens' fuel window, and also shows how much faster the RBR is with the much heavier fuel load compare to BGP...

I have no issue with Mark's move on Rubens(no more than with MS's similar move at the start, or Lewis's version of it, ok maybe the timing seems kinda odd, I would've chopped earlier, lol), just I find it amusing in that Mark, in his role as GPDA's chair have openly criticized MS and Ham in the past for it, and how interesting that he did the exact same thing....reflex...its a bitch...lol

Want to see a more extreme case of the move, look at the Toronto Indy race of Helio on Paul Tracy.....that was quite intentional and both came out DNFed....

User avatar
paused
0
Joined: 30 Mar 2009, 01:16

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

ISLAMATRON wrote:
paused wrote:IMO the move with Rubens was a bit too aggresive. He really only need to squeeze him rather than belt him but then again probabky no worse that at least 10 moves from Lewis in 07/08.
List out those 10 times when Lewis hit anyone... exactly... bullshit.
People really do like arguing on this board don't they? I didn't say lewis hit other cars 10 times in 07/08. However, whether you hit someone is not really the be all and end all of whether a move is agressive or not.

If you send a flyer down the inside knowing that if the other car turns in you will have an accident, then in my view that is not any less agressive than what Mark did. I did after all say that it was "too agressive" didn't I? Just relax.

Michiba
Michiba
4
Joined: 28 Apr 2008, 08:58

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

djos wrote:
Michiba wrote:yes, I did see that djos, but I also saw the post race interview, which I think was quite telling.

Sure, no one likes to lose or come second, but I made a reference to last year, when he won. Everyone was saying what a nice guy he is etc. I just think that if that was true, he wouldn't act like he did during the interview.

I don't necessarily see it as a bad thing, just that he's not as sporting as I was made to believe. Having said that, if he keeps it up (his attitude), I think he can become the next schumacher for sure. You don't win races by thinking that it's ok to come 2nd.
Personally I thought these comments from Vettel were extreemly Sporting:
“Congratulations to Mark,” Vettel underlined. “He was unbeatable today – he was quicker than all of us, so he totally deserved to win. I'm very happy with the result, and in the end it was a good recovery. It was quite a bad start and I had all the KERS cars around me – I got passed by both the McLarens and even Felipe. It was quite difficult to start fourth and go into the first corner in eighth or something.

“I then struggled a lot with the soft tyres in the first stint and was in a lot of traffic. I could have gone quicker, but there was no way to pass Felipe, as he always used the special button when I was quite close. Therefore I was lucky to have the right strategy, as that pulled us back to second position but Felipe didn't stop pushing, so it was hard until the end of the race.

“We had to fight, but it's another one-two finish for the team and I'm happy. I'd be lying if I said I'm very pleased with second, as of course I wanted to win, but yesterday Mark did a better job and that's why today he totally deserves the win – it's a good fight between us, so I'm looking forward to the next races.”

Vettel: Webber was 'unbeatable' – and totally deserved to win
Fair enough. I had mainly based my opinion on his demeanor, and his reaction to Massa joking with him.

Will be interesting to watch the fight between Vettel and Webber for the rest of the season, given that they both have great chances now to win, unlike the battle between Button and Rubens.

User avatar
ISLAMATRON
0
Joined: 01 Oct 2008, 18:29

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

paused wrote:
ISLAMATRON wrote:
paused wrote:IMO the move with Rubens was a bit too aggresive. He really only need to squeeze him rather than belt him but then again probabky no worse that at least 10 moves from Lewis in 07/08.
List out those 10 times when Lewis hit anyone... exactly... bullshit.
People really do like arguing on this board don't they? I didn't say lewis hit other cars 10 times in 07/08. However, whether you hit someone is not really the be all and end all of whether a move is agressive or not.

If you send a flyer down the inside knowing that if the other car turns in you will have an accident, then in my view that is not any less agressive than what Mark did. I did after all say that it was "too agressive" didn't I? Just relax.
Lewis understands, unlike you, that passing is 90% about positioning, While you may think he is "sending a flyer" down the inside, you can see that he is totally in control of his car, by the mere fact that he does not hit the other car, and that he leaves them ample racing room(a great majority of the time). Even in Japan last year he did not hit KIMi, although he destroyed his tire trying to avoid the contact.

The entire point of positioning yourself on the inside for an outbraking maneuver, is to place yourself where your opposition has no other choice but to slow down and cede the position

User avatar
jon-mullen
1
Joined: 10 Sep 2008, 02:56
Location: Big Blue Nation

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

Shrek wrote:Is it just me or does Kimi always have bad luck at least when he's not winning.
LOL, I was thinking the same thing during the race. I guess if he had to use all of his luck up, though, Brazil 07 was the place to do it.
Loud idiot in red since 2010
United States Grand Prix Club, because there's more to racing than NASCAR

User avatar
paused
0
Joined: 30 Mar 2009, 01:16

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

ISLAMATRON wrote:
Lewis understands, unlike you, that passing is 90% about positioning, While you may think he is "sending a flyer" down the inside, you can see that he is totally in control of his car, by the mere fact that he does not hit the other car, and that he leaves them ample racing room(a great majority of the time). Even in Japan last year he did not hit KIMi, although he destroyed his tire trying to avoid the contact.

The entire point of positioning yourself on the inside for an outbraking maneuver, is to place yourself where your opposition has no other choice but to slow down and cede the position
Ok one eye! Sorry to infur Lewis is not perfect. How misguided of me! I wonder if I started a thread call "Lewis is not an agressive driver" how that debate may go. Suggest you read what is being said before you get too hot under the collar.

andartop
andartop
14
Joined: 08 Jun 2008, 22:01
Location: London, UK

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

Shrek wrote:Is it just me or does Kimi always have bad luck at least when he's not winning.
Actually, Kimi has bad luck and mechanical failures or accidents whenever Michael Schumacher is present. I've said that before but people don't believe me. Just check it and see!
The most merciful thing in the world, I think, is the inability of the human mind to correlate all its contents. H.P.Lovecraft

andartop
andartop
14
Joined: 08 Jun 2008, 22:01
Location: London, UK

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

ISLAMATRON wrote:But like a said, merely a racing incident.
I won't argue with that mate. All I've been saying all along is that he should know better than to attack the first corner like there's no tomorrow and get himself caught up in a silly first corner incident, ruining his race. One of the first things rookies learn in F1 (except Sato).
The most merciful thing in the world, I think, is the inability of the human mind to correlate all its contents. H.P.Lovecraft

User avatar
ISLAMATRON
0
Joined: 01 Oct 2008, 18:29

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

--- happens whether you are attacking going into the first corner or bringing up the rear like the STR running into a spinning Truilli. Rubens got banged into by Webber, he didnt do anything to deserve it. Your destiny is just what it is... just look at Webber. That kind of blindingly quick start didnt look like anything rookieish to me.

User avatar
megz
1
Joined: 14 Mar 2007, 09:57
Location: New Zealand

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

ISLAMATRON wrote:
Lewis understands, unlike you, that passing is 90% about positioning, While you may think he is "sending a flyer" down the inside, you can see that he is totally in control of his car, by the mere fact that he does not hit the other car, and that he leaves them ample racing room(a great majority of the time). Even in Japan last year he did not hit KIMi, although he destroyed his tire trying to avoid the contact.

The entire point of positioning yourself on the inside for an outbraking maneuver, is to place yourself where your opposition has no other choice but to slow down and cede the position
Only you can't exactly say you are in control when your brakes are completely locked. So, we have Japan 2008 at the very least. Then we have Hamilton practically running Glock and Webber off the road in Monza in '08, Spa '08 he was locked up going into bus stop. He may not have hit anyone (severely at least) but he has made plenty of over the top aggressive moves.

I love how you accuse other people of wicked anti-Hamilton bias and then go and and pick a fight while heaping praise on another driver... #-o

I think we all need to put our emotions aside and look more at the subjective facts.

User avatar
ISLAMATRON
0
Joined: 01 Oct 2008, 18:29

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

megz wrote:Only you can't exactly say you are in control when your brakes are completely locked. So, we have Japan 2008 at the very least. Then we have Hamilton practically running Glock and Webber off the road in Monza in '08, Spa '08 he was locked up going into bus stop. He may not have hit anyone (severely at least) but he has made plenty of over the top aggressive moves.

I love how you accuse other people of wicked anti-Hamilton bias and then go and and pick a fight while heaping praise on another driver... #-o

I think we all need to put our emotions aside and look more at the subjective facts.
I Guess "over the top aggressive moves" is subjective... but thats what it seems to take to get passes done in F1 these days... Monza 08 was wet, so was spa... I cut everybody a little slack in the rain... maybe you guys like to watch the Truilli trains

User avatar
ringo
230
Joined: 29 Mar 2009, 10:57

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

Hamilton is agressive in the right ways, he does not contact, he is Lewis the merciful, he gives the other drivers 2 options.. concede or face consequences. lol

I am yet to see Lewis do anything relating to hitting someone to end their race. All he does is position himself to herd the sheep onto the grass. :lol:
If they don't want to be droved they can brake.

This incident is not hamilton's fault, he cant be blamed for a rear ender, remeber piquet and buemi in monaco? Just plain bad luck.
For Sure!!

User avatar
hulmerist
0
Joined: 12 Feb 2009, 20:59

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

andartop wrote:
ISLAMATRON wrote:But like a said, merely a racing incident.
I won't argue with that mate. All I've been saying all along is that he should know better than to attack the first corner like there's no tomorrow and get himself caught up in a silly first corner incident, ruining his race. One of the first things rookies learn in F1 (except Sato).
surely being in the lead going into the first corner would be the safest place?

he would've probably gone onto the run off without the puncture but not so much, would've ended up in the top 3 definitely

DaveKillens
DaveKillens
34
Joined: 20 Jan 2005, 04:02

Re: German Gp 2009 - Nürburgring

Post

Congratulations to Mark Webber on a well-deserved win. The Red Bull cars proved they are quicker than the Brawns in cool conditions. Trouble is, most of the races remaining will be much warmer.
Whenever any driver attempts a banzai move on the start, it is fraught with risks. This time, Hamilton's excessive aggressiveness worked against him, and he lost. If you risk all, sometimes you lose all.
I can understand Reuben's paranoia and frustration. Just like him, ever since Spain, I am firmly convinced Brawn has Button tagged as the number one driver. Brawn may try to disclipine Reubens, but I suspect it won't work. Right now, Brawn need Barrichello a lot more than Barrichello needs them.
Racing should be decided on the track, not the court room.