Honda returns to F1 in 2015

Post here all non technical related topics about Formula One. This includes race results, discussions, testing analysis etc. TV coverage and other personal questions should be in Off topic chat.
User avatar
dren
226
Joined: 03 Mar 2010, 14:14

Re: More Honda Rumor Fuel

Post

It would probably benefit Honda to wait out the 2014 season. The technical working group will likely change the power unit regulations after the 2014 season. Honda end up not wasting resources for 2014 that way.
Honda!

User avatar
turbof1
Moderator
Joined: 19 Jul 2012, 21:36
Location: MountDoom CFD Matrix

Re: More Honda Rumor Fuel

Post

dren wrote:It would probably benefit Honda to wait out the 2014 season. The technical working group will likely change the power unit regulations after the 2014 season. Honda end up not wasting resources for 2014 that way.
Then again, they would have one year less of on-track data.

Can the m-gu's be seperately developed by the individual teams? Honda has little experience in energy recovery systems; McLaren has alot actually, but if Honda has to produce that too, it'll put them at a disadvantage.
#AeroFrodo

ESPImperium
ESPImperium
64
Joined: 06 Apr 2008, 00:08
Location: Glasgow, Scotland

Re: More Honda Rumor Fuel

Post

Cam wrote:A clean straight split is what everyone will want. When McLaren split with Hamilton, McLaren also lost the beloved and faithfull dog - which hurts. It'll be keen to man up or risk being seen as a soft touch.

Whether or not Honda is ready for 2014 is another story. The last thing they need is to rush in and see failing engines with turbo pieces strewn all over the main straight and poor performance. That said, most engine suppliers run that risk, so if Honda hold out until 2015, they run the risk of loosing valuable track time to develop further. What to do?

A common sense approach would be a 'soft launch' for Honda, say with Marussia. Maybe even un-brand the engines. Honda gets a nice PR story helping the underdog, while saving face if it all goes pear shaped. That's 12 months extra to develop their main engine on the test bed, 12 months developing with track time and 12 months peering into the Mercs donk.

Honda are in the box seat here and I doubt they'll be pushed one way or the other. One customers cash for a F1 engine as opposed to a misfired global branding exercise - is a no brainer to have all your ducks lined up before jumping into anything.

After all, Honda may not be coming in at all.......
That makes sense to a point. Maybes under the Mugen brand? I can see 2014 being a year of nothing but relyability problems anyways. I do find it intresting that LMP1 and LMP2 will be able to use V6 power as Renault are likley to return with Signature Team for one car and one other team for an assault on LMP2 next year. This will also be data gathering as well for the engine suppliers.
turbof1 wrote:
dren wrote:It would probably benefit Honda to wait out the 2014 season. The technical working group will likely change the power unit regulations after the 2014 season. Honda end up not wasting resources for 2014 that way.
Then again, they would have one year less of on-track data.

Can the m-gu's be seperately developed by the individual teams? Honda has little experience in energy recovery systems; McLaren has alot actually, but if Honda has to produce that too, it'll put them at a disadvantage.
This is where it may be a ideal marrage, Honda will learn about ERS and electronic system integration on a power unit, but McLaren learn a great deal about how to make a F1 engine in preperation for a McLaren-McLaren for 2022-2024 when the next F1 engine is due.

User avatar
turbof1
Moderator
Joined: 19 Jul 2012, 21:36
Location: MountDoom CFD Matrix

Re: More Honda Rumor Fuel

Post

McLaren actually has already experience at building engines, albeit only for the mp4-12c road car. They wanted a very specific engine built for that car, but could not find an engine builder to do so, after which they just built their own one. I think they want to keep f1 engines outsourced to keep costs in check.
#AeroFrodo

User avatar
WhiteBlue
92
Joined: 14 Apr 2008, 20:58
Location: WhiteBlue Country

Re: More Honda Rumor Fuel

Post

At one stage Volökswagen is likely to switch Porsche from LeMans to F1. It is an option that was already build into the LeMans plan. So it is a question of the right conditions in F1 to appear that will cause them to throw that switch. By that I mean the right set of rules and a sensible business proposition. As it stands only Bernie wins and no manufacturer. That has got to change for VW to come on board.
Formula One's fundamental ethos is about success coming to those with the most ingenious engineering and best .............................. organization, not to those with the biggest budget. (Dave Richards)

User avatar
dren
226
Joined: 03 Mar 2010, 14:14

Re: More Honda Rumor Fuel

Post

turbof1 wrote:
dren wrote:It would probably benefit Honda to wait out the 2014 season. The technical working group will likely change the power unit regulations after the 2014 season. Honda end up not wasting resources for 2014 that way.
Then again, they would have one year less of on-track data.

Can the m-gu's be seperately developed by the individual teams? Honda has little experience in energy recovery systems; McLaren has alot actually, but if Honda has to produce that too, it'll put them at a disadvantage.
Honda can use the time to continue development. Honda developed an in-house KERS system to be used in 2009, but took it with them when they exited F1. They have had hybrid cars on the road for close to 15 years. They may not have the F1 KERS experience that other teams do, but they certainly are not jumping into uncharted territory. The development work on the new NSX will help them as well.
Honda!

User avatar
FW17
169
Joined: 06 Jan 2010, 10:56

Re: More Honda Rumor Fuel

Post

WhiteBlue wrote:At one stage Volökswagen is likely to switch Porsche from LeMans to F1. It is an option that was already build into the LeMans plan. So it is a question of the right conditions in F1 to appear that will cause them to throw that switch. By that I mean the right set of rules and a sensible business proposition. As it stands only Bernie wins and no manufacturer. That has got to change for VW to come on board.

Even if they don't enter F1 atleast hoping that Porsche or some other LeMans manufacturer would develop a 1.6 V6 that could become the base for customer engine. Could then be modded to F1 standard by guys like JUDD, HART, ILMOR etc.

With 2 works teams and 3 manufactures divided among the teams does not sound great for F1.

Richard
Richard
Moderator
Joined: 15 Apr 2009, 14:41
Location: UK

Re: More Honda Rumor Fuel

Post

turbof1 wrote:McLaren actually has already experience at building engines, albeit only for the mp4-12c road car. They wanted a very specific engine built for that car, but could not find an engine builder to do so, after which they just built their own one. I think they want to keep f1 engines outsourced to keep costs in check.
I thought the MP4-12C engine was made by Ricardo? Yes it was specifically developed in a very close partnership, but McLaren do not have the capability to build engines in-house. Also, it's vague how much of the design input came from McLaren or Ricardo, as well as Menard & Mahle. See Joe Saward comment at the bottom of here - http://joesaward.wordpress.com/2012/01/ ... n-mclaren/

Personally, I suspect they have the capability to build their own F1 engine in some joint venture with Ricardo's engine team. that would take a lot of pain though, they're starting at the bottom of the learning curve, plus a lot of cash. Honda have the advantage of a huge engine development capability so they'll start higher up the learning curve. However even Honda don't have much recent F1 experience so they'll take a few seasons to hit the top.

wunderkind
wunderkind
5
Joined: 04 Apr 2007, 06:12

Re: More Honda Rumor Fuel

Post

The engine of the MP4-12C is actually not an original McLaren design. It was based on a defunct Nissan GT1 racing engine from the late 1990's. McLaren wanted to find a V8 engine that fit their physical requirements and the Nissan engine was the one they found. Then Ricardo was tasked to engineer and develop it.

User avatar
dren
226
Joined: 03 Mar 2010, 14:14

Re: More Honda Rumor Fuel

Post

richard_leeds wrote:I thought the MP4-12C was made by Ricardo? Yes it was specifically developed in a very close partnership, but McLaren do not have the capability to build engines in-house. Also, it's vague how much of the design input came from McLaren or Ricardo, as well as Menard & Mahle. See Joe Saward comment at the bottom of here - http://joesaward.wordpress.com/2012/01/ ... n-mclaren/

Personally, I suspect they have the capability to build their own F1 engine in some joint venture with Ricardo's engine team. that would take a lot of pain though of starring at the bottom of the learning curve, plus a lot of cash. Honda have the advantage of a huge engine development capability so they'll start higher up the learning curve. However even Honda don't have much recent F1 experience so they'll take a few seasons to hit the top.
The biggest issue with Mclaren not building their own engines is likely money. They took on sizeable debt to fund the sports car side of the business. I expect them to build their own engines in the distant future if the sports car side takes off.
Honda!

User avatar
turbof1
Moderator
Joined: 19 Jul 2012, 21:36
Location: MountDoom CFD Matrix

Re: More Honda Rumor Fuel

Post

richard_leeds wrote:
turbof1 wrote:McLaren actually has already experience at building engines, albeit only for the mp4-12c road car. They wanted a very specific engine built for that car, but could not find an engine builder to do so, after which they just built their own one. I think they want to keep f1 engines outsourced to keep costs in check.
I thought the MP4-12C was made by Ricardo? Yes it was specifically developed in a very close partnership, but McLaren do not have the capability to build engines in-house. Also, it's vague how much of the design input came from McLaren or Ricardo, as well as Menard & Mahle. See Joe Saward comment at the bottom of here - http://joesaward.wordpress.com/2012/01/ ... n-mclaren/

Personally, I suspect they have the capability to build their own F1 engine in some joint venture with Ricardo's engine team. that would take a lot of pain though, they're starting at the bottom of the learning curve, plus a lot of cash. Honda have the advantage of a huge engine development capability so they'll start higher up the learning curve. However even Honda don't have much recent F1 experience so they'll take a few seasons to hit the top.
Thanks for that clarification! I was under the impression they did made the engine in-house (or at the very least designed it completely), so yeah thank you for pointing that out.
#AeroFrodo

User avatar
Turbo
0
Joined: 08 Mar 2013, 03:28
Location: NJ

Re: More Honda Rumor Fuel

Post

Honda is having a hard time in Indy competing with Chevy. Maybe they will leave Indy and focus on F1.

Sombrero
Sombrero
126
Joined: 22 Feb 2012, 20:18

Re: More Honda Rumor Fuel

Post

Honda is having a hard time in Indy competing with Chevy. Maybe they will leave Indy and focus on F1.
The Penske Racing is using Chevy's that the main reason why Honda has a hard time...

Leon
Leon
17
Joined: 23 Feb 2011, 21:58
Location: Armenia

Re: More Honda Rumor Fuel

Post

McLaren with Ferrari engine!11 :D
"Clouds now and again
give a soul some respite from
moon-gazing-behold."

Matsuo Basho

oT v1
oT v1
0
Joined: 21 May 2012, 15:46

Re: More Honda Rumor Fuel

Post

Leon wrote:McLaren with Ferrari engine!11 :D
complete with chocolate cylinders and pistons....

DNF - engine
DNF - engine
DNF - engine
.
.
.
The Power of Dreams