Sierra117 wrote: ↑24 Feb 2019, 09:23
As for Ted, to the gentleman who said he talks like he knows it all, no, I have never heard Ted say anything without explicitly stating "well, I'm not a racing driver/engineer ..."
I mean the guy literally has a NOTEBOOK where he writes down quotes and facts as he learns them from authorirative sources on track and then conveys them to us. IMO big mistake to let him go and testing coverage has shown that. I feel there is a certain sound, persona and feel required in presenting and Ted had an excellent balance of it. The rest sound either too technical and boring or too forced and fake.
this, he is a perfect presenter for the role he filled, no he doesn't understand things at more than a superficial level but that's not what his job requires, sure the members of this forum would probably love more deep analysis but we are a very small part of the total audience and the " notebook " segments are initially part of the main broadcast which happened to be repeated later as a separate show. in many ways ted reminds me of Nick Daman from radio le mans, not too reverential of people's reputation and prepared to take interviews in unlikely directions.
re the others, i broadly agree though have to add that Chandhok has an almost literal encyclopedic knowledge of the history of F1, he loves the sport and given the chance, he is a very natural presenter with an easy to listen to style, the questions are, will sky allow him to be himself? and is he the person to present the notebook ?
Crofty is far better than a lot of those that came before him, we all remember Walker and Hunt for a reason, it's that what came after was awful, Brundle is "ageing fast" but he makes a good counter to Crofty in race broadcasts though i must admit i like the practice sessions whenever its Crofty and Herbert, that feels like a good cricket commentary, filling in what is fairly repetitive viewing with a decent mix of humour and information.
I'm not convinced by Button, when ever i've heard him talk, he's come over as a bit bland, hopefully he'll prove me wrong