Schumi comes back

Post here all non technical related topics about Formula One. This includes race results, discussions, testing analysis etc. TV coverage and other personal questions should be in Off topic chat.
User avatar
siskue2005
70
Joined: 11 May 2007, 21:50

Re: Schumi comes back

Post

Giblet wrote:But it looks sooooo huuuungryyyyyyyy.......
:lol: :lol:

Conceptual
Conceptual
0
Joined: 15 Nov 2007, 03:33

Re: Schumi comes back

Post

ISLAMATRON wrote:
jason.parker.86 wrote:with Gp2 tyres (which one can buy from eBay).

Finally - how anyone can suggest the GP2 tyre is the same as a F1 tyre needs their head testing. They are both round, and rubber but thats where the simularities end. They have a complete different make-up, differnt compounds etc!

The absurdity of that statement in bold is self evident...

and like others have pointed out, the F2007 on the GP2 tires was faster than the F60 test from this winter, if that does not speak of the similarity of the GP2 tire then I dont know what does.

Those of us who have been watching this sport for a while remember that when GP2 debuted they ran the grooved tires but the next year switched to a slick tire and the reason given was that GP2 was to be a test bed for technology and rules for F1 as well as a feeder series. Bridgestone often spoke about the similarities between its GP2 slicks and what it was developing for F1, and this is not the first time a GP2 tire has been fitted onto an F1 machine.

The GP2 tires are the exact same dimension as the F1 tires and I would guess they are made on the same exact machines, yes the construction(mainly side wall stiffness) and compound may vary slightly but not by too much seeing that the 2 series run on the same venues.

The 2 compounds cannot be too different, or else there would be compatability problems when they run the same track on the same weekends. And the durability must be there seeing how the GP2 feature races are more than half(60%) the length of the F1 race.
One has to wonder if the GP2 tyres have a complimentary compound to F1 so they can help the "rubbering in" of the track over the weekend...

Conceptual
Conceptual
0
Joined: 15 Nov 2007, 03:33

Re: Schumi comes back

Post

dave34m wrote:Well we all should care, there are rules set out for the season. Toro Rosso had to send a 19 year kid out on track without a single lap in a F1 car, just think about that for a moment, not a single lap before having compete against the top drivers anywhere in cars they had developed all year.

OK so they could have used an older car but that wouldnt help much really and Schumacher driving the F2007 is probably is a good compromise for Ferrari in getting trained up a bit but having a days testing in the F60 should not be allowed. Honestly we all should care, Schumacher has 3 free practice sessions before the race, the same as Alguersuari had, there really is no good reason for Ferrari to have special treatment here. If he is a god on the track as some here clearly believe then he won't need it.
More pure ignorance.

Can you please direct us to the article where a member of STR said that they asked for a test day with Jaime and were denied?

Like Haug said, "Ask and thou shalt receive."

So, is the argument that Ferrari even asked?

andartop
andartop
14
Joined: 08 Jun 2008, 22:01
Location: London, UK

Re: Schumi comes back

Post

dave34m wrote:...OK so they could have used an older car but that wouldnt help much really..
I thought it actually might have helped a lot. Maybe they could set up an older car to simulate similar to 2009 levels of grip, and that could have given Jaimie quite an accurate idea of what to expect..

It's very simple, really. Ferrari didn't cheat, and they didn't even pretend: they said that MS wants to be better prepared and they asked for permission!
The most merciful thing in the world, I think, is the inability of the human mind to correlate all its contents. H.P.Lovecraft

User avatar
WhiteBlue
92
Joined: 14 Apr 2008, 20:58
Location: WhiteBlue Country

Re: Schumi comes back

Post

WhiteBlue wrote:Kimi is probably completely umperturbated. He will say something like this: "I drive the car and we are still not fast enough. The car needs more hard work by the team. There is a second car and I don't really care who drives it."
Ok, this is what Kimi actually said:
"It makes no difference to me who drives the second Ferrari. It'll be nice to have a team-mate. We've raced closely before."
I am a mind reader! :mrgreen:
Formula One's fundamental ethos is about success coming to those with the most ingenious engineering and best .............................. organization, not to those with the biggest budget. (Dave Richards)

James
James
0
Joined: 03 Aug 2009, 12:41

Re: Schumi comes back

Post

I think the testing ban was designed to cut the cost of car development throughout the year, not hamper a driver's readiness to race. Schumacher would have always been the most experienced driver there, I dont think letting him test would give an unfair advantage and Haug's comments on autosport sugest that str would have been treated the same if they had asked.

I dont think schumacher driving the f2007 is any different then kimi driving rally cars in the break. And whilst schumacher has his ay in the f60 it won't carry any new parts an they won't have anything to compare it's performance too so i highly doubt it will aid the cars development in anyway just allow schumacher some cockpit time before the race weekend.

RacingManiac
RacingManiac
9
Joined: 22 Nov 2004, 02:29

Re: Schumi comes back

Post

andartop wrote:
dave34m wrote:...OK so they could have used an older car but that wouldnt help much really..
I thought it actually might have helped a lot. Maybe they could set up an older car to simulate similar to 2009 levels of grip, and that could have given Jaimie quite an accurate idea of what to expect..
Not only that, but also the physical demend of driving a F1 car for 90 mins.....F3 races lasts probably less than a third of that, and they don't pull 4Gs in braking and cornering.....and they also have more tire than they have power....its for the rest of the grid and FIA to know that, yes, he can handle a F1 car without getting destroyed physically for a whole race...

RacingManiac
RacingManiac
9
Joined: 22 Nov 2004, 02:29

Re: Schumi comes back

Post

http://www.autosport.com/news/report.php/id/77534

I think its understandable, as I've mentioned it makes little sense for him to test the F60 if all he needs to physical acclimatization to a F1 car's cornering force. If the F2007+GP2 tires can do the trick, he can just do that for 2 weeks.

On the flipside to this, this is just Williams getting back to FOTA.....I expect to see more of this kind of relationship between the FOTA vs non-FOTA thing in the future...

User avatar
djos
113
Joined: 19 May 2006, 06:09
Location: Melbourne, Australia

Re: Schumi comes back

Post

RacingManiac wrote:http://www.autosport.com/news/report.php/id/77534

I think its understandable, as I've mentioned it makes little sense for him to test the F60 if all he needs to physical acclimatization to a F1 car's cornering force. If the F2007+GP2 tires can do the trick, he can just do that for 2 weeks.

On the flipside to this, this is just Williams getting back to FOTA.....I expect to see more of this kind of relationship between the FOTA vs non-FOTA thing in the future...
Ah the irony, it used to be Ferrari playing stupid games and opposing things that all the other teams agreed on, now it's Williams!!! Ah how times have changed! #-o
"In downforce we trust"

User avatar
siskue2005
70
Joined: 11 May 2007, 21:50

Re: Schumi comes back

Post

djos wrote:
RacingManiac wrote:http://www.autosport.com/news/report.php/id/77534

I think its understandable, as I've mentioned it makes little sense for him to test the F60 if all he needs to physical acclimatization to a F1 car's cornering force. If the F2007+GP2 tires can do the trick, he can just do that for 2 weeks.

On the flipside to this, this is just Williams getting back to FOTA.....I expect to see more of this kind of relationship between the FOTA vs non-FOTA thing in the future...
Ah the irony, it used to be Ferrari playing stupid games and opposing things that all the other teams agreed on, now it's Williams!!! Ah how times have changed! #-o
Ferrari playing stupid games and opposing, ahem excuse me could you list them with proper proof?

User avatar
siskue2005
70
Joined: 11 May 2007, 21:50

Re: Schumi comes back

Post

RacingManiac wrote:http://www.autosport.com/news/report.php/id/77534

I think its understandable, as I've mentioned it makes little sense for him to test the F60 if all he needs to physical acclimatization to a F1 car's cornering force. If the F2007+GP2 tires can do the trick, he can just do that for 2 weeks.

On the flipside to this, this is just Williams getting back to FOTA.....I expect to see more of this kind of relationship between the FOTA vs non-FOTA thing in the future...
good that Williams opposed this
otherwise all ferrari haters would be cryiing how ferrari and FIA bend rules...blah blah blah

they asked for it [which anyone can do]
and one rejected it...maybe taking a punch at FOTA as u mentioned

User avatar
djos
113
Joined: 19 May 2006, 06:09
Location: Melbourne, Australia

Re: Schumi comes back

Post

siskue2005 wrote:
djos wrote: Ah the irony, it used to be Ferrari playing stupid games and opposing things that all the other teams agreed on, now it's Williams!!! Ah how times have changed! #-o
Ferrari playing stupid games and opposing, ahem excuse me could you list them with proper proof?
Certainly, I haven't forgotten Ferrari's actions against Minardi in 2005:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/column ... spute.html
The increasingly bitter dispute between Formula One's harmless plodders, Minardi, and the sport's most powerful team, Ferrari, escalated dramatically yesterday, leaving Minardi's participation in the Australian Grand Prix in doubt.

A frantic phone call in the early hours of the Australian morning to Italy ended abruptly with Jean Todt, Ferrari's general manager, refusing to yield to a request by Minardi's owner, Paul Stoddart, to run his cars according to 2004 aerodynamic specifications. Ferrari contend that they cannot agree to the Minardi request because it would not be fair.

The late intervention of Bernie Ecclestone, the Formula One commercial rights holder, guaranteed that Minardi would at least pass scrutineering today on safety grounds. But if Ferrari protest the legality of Stoddart's cars, the stewards would have no choice but to bar them entry.

Mindful that Ferrari are the only team not to acquiesce to what has become a desperate plea – one that in terms of performance gain would barely threaten the equally benign Jordan – it is difficult not to agree with Stoddart's damning assessment of Ferrari's position.
and there are other examples that I cant be bothered providing where all teams reached an agreement on something only to have the deal scuppered by Ferrari.
"In downforce we trust"

User avatar
Rob W
0
Joined: 18 Aug 2006, 03:28

Re: Schumi comes back

Post

RacingManiac wrote:...it makes little sense for him to test the F60 if all he needs to physical acclimatization to a F1 car's cornering force. If the F2007+GP2 tires can do the trick, he can just do that for 2 weeks.
I agree, and I think Frank Williams once again is the voice of reason. His reasoning is sound and there is not really much justification for allowing Ferrari any special dispensation.

As we've seen with Brawn in the last couple of races, each new track is an opportunity to discover your the car doesn't handle as expected - tires, set-up or whatever - they and every other team has available FP1 and 2 to sort their issues out for the race. I can't see any reason so why on earth Ferrari should be allowed any more than the rest.
Last edited by Rob W on 03 Aug 2009, 16:34, edited 1 time in total.

axle
axle
3
Joined: 22 Jun 2004, 14:45
Location: Norfolk, UK

Re: Schumi comes back

Post

I can fully understand Williams' viewpoint - if a test day is allowed then every team should be testing...

It's harsh, but, it's fair...
- Axle

User avatar
WhiteBlue
92
Joined: 14 Apr 2008, 20:58
Location: WhiteBlue Country

Re: Schumi comes back

Post

I have predicted that move. It is understandable because why should Williams give freebies to Ferrari. They are competing for constructor points and each point means money. The official reasoning is just PC bull manure.
Formula One's fundamental ethos is about success coming to those with the most ingenious engineering and best .............................. organization, not to those with the biggest budget. (Dave Richards)