Spot on.
Spot on.
Charles isn’t fighting for WDC, he’s looking at WCC as he already said in interviews. Fighting for scraps isn’t exciting and risking crashing against your team mate is not smart. They could have left fighting at the end of the race when they were 2nd and 3rd and maximized team points.yooogurt wrote:It's funny, considering that after Carlos overtook Charles, the engineer told Charles to save tires and attack less in turn 10 (I believe), and if Binnotto had been in Vasseur's place, he would have been eaten with giblets right nowScuderiaLeo wrote: ↑19 Oct 2024, 21:24Literally as I'm typing this, an interview came on my TV of Vasseur saying at no point did they think about team orders or telling them to stop.
Did you see those mistakes? lap by lap? I didn't.ScuderiaLeo wrote: ↑19 Oct 2024, 21:47Leclerc makes mistakes like any other human so you can't eliminate the possibility of him making them.
Well just without the early fight it would have been an easy 2-3, maybe more, at least without Max's easy walk, which is obviously more favorable to the WCC.dialtone wrote: ↑19 Oct 2024, 21:52Charles isn’t fighting for WDC, he’s looking at WCC as he already said in interviews. Fighting for scraps isn’t exciting and risking crashing against your team mate is not smart. They could have left fighting at the end of the race when they were 2nd and 3rd and maximized team points.
Certain drivers deal with certain situations better than others. Instead of just always assuming Charles is intentionally being slow early in the stint, you could also view it from another perspective and notice that this is actually a pattern and perhaps Charles is just weaker earlier on the stint. It's not just against Carlos that he has struggled like this at the beginning of the stints.yooogurt wrote: ↑19 Oct 2024, 21:46Yes he was, but how many moments have you seen, when a teammate with the same tires in drs train was faster than his teammate at the beginning of the race on a equal car?
I don't believe that it was a matter of skill, and I can't find any other explanation than that Charles had less battery power.
You have an opinion and are justifying it. Charles takes time to warm up tires and today used battery in the attempt with george. Sainz never took off.Emag wrote:Certain drivers deal with certain situations better than others. Instead of just always assuming Charles is intentionally being slow early in the stint, you could also view it from another perspective and notice that this is actually a pattern and perhaps Charles is just weaker earlier on the stint. It's not just against Carlos that he has struggled like this at the beginning of the stints.yooogurt wrote: ↑19 Oct 2024, 21:46Yes he was, but how many moments have you seen, when a teammate with the same tires in drs train was faster than his teammate at the beginning of the race on a equal car?
I don't believe that it was a matter of skill, and I can't find any other explanation than that Charles had less battery power.
It's funny how these primary details get lost when everything works outf1316 wrote: ↑19 Oct 2024, 22:03The most exciting thing, of course, is that the car was still competitive on this more traditional circuit - I think that’s all the confirmation we need in the efficacy of the Monza floor and bodes well for the rest of the year.
Even more so if you think that most other cars brought updates and the “final upgrade” Fred spoke about must therefore still be in the pipeline .
I don't really have the opinion you think I have. My opinion is that Charles is a generational talent and on the same tier with Max, Lewis and Alonso (prime) of the current grid.dialtone wrote: ↑19 Oct 2024, 22:09You have an opinion and are justifying it. Charles takes time to warm up tires and today used battery in the attempt with george. Sainz never took off.Emag wrote:Certain drivers deal with certain situations better than others. Instead of just always assuming Charles is intentionally being slow early in the stint, you could also view it from another perspective and notice that this is actually a pattern and perhaps Charles is just weaker earlier on the stint. It's not just against Carlos that he has struggled like this at the beginning of the stints.yooogurt wrote: ↑19 Oct 2024, 21:46
Yes he was, but how many moments have you seen, when a teammate with the same tires in drs train was faster than his teammate at the beginning of the race on a equal car?
I don't believe that it was a matter of skill, and I can't find any other explanation than that Charles had less battery power.
I’m not saying your opinion of charles is wrong. Just that you made up your mind on this race.Emag wrote:
I don't really have the opinion you think I have. My opinion is that Charles is a generational talent and on the same tier with Max, Lewis and Alonso (prime) of the current grid.
My other opinion is that I think the expectation that people have here for Carlos to be a "good boy" and sit back to let Charles to charge up and get the results in the end is not realistic. Especially when the team has sacked him for next year. There is no incentive for him to give up a position to Leclerc if he has the pace to fight him. Even more so on a sprint.
Carlos took advantage of Charles' weak(er) pace at the start. You think that's because he was attacking George and I also disagree with that. There wasn't any serious attempt by Charles at any place in the track where it would suggest heavy battery usage. It also doesn't make sense to drain the battery like that early on in the race.
I would believe it if Charles didn't have drs, and I also remembered over the years that Charles is better at the beginning of the stint and Carlos pulls up at the end (not always btw), and today's situation reminds me of the Austrian 2022 sprint, where we also lost positions because Carlos decided to attack his teammate at the beginning.