Feels like with Horner comments Perez isn't there next year its just if they make the move before the end of the season or next year.PapayaFan481 wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 16:23And when will they decide if they bring a new 2md driver? Lol
I keep track of the introductions of new parts (ICE linked below, others on request, if anyone is interested), but that list obviously doesn't include any information about what engine was used at which race, unfortunately
Great! Thank you!search wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 18:04I keep track of the introductions of new parts (ICE linked below, others on request, if anyone is interested), but that list obviously doesn't include any information about what engine was used at which race, unfortunately
https://i.imgur.com/W9bWI5m.png
no idea if Verstappen ever got to use the Melbourne and/or Canada engine again, for example.
You know what, I agree. There definitely needs to be a protest, Norris going off track to overtake was a clear 10s penalty that simply had to be given. He released his brakes earlier than ever and had a throttle blip to get ahead of apex. I don't think he was making that corner, like Horner himself said.pantherxxx wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 14:52Apparently two stewards for the Mexican Grand Prix were Johnny Herbert and Tim Mayer (son of McLaren co-founder Teddy Mayer).
Do you remember that in 2021 they wanted to remove one of the stewards because he had a Honda dealership? Now British and Mclaren-linked stewards are punishing Max.
Red Bull should protest because of conflict of interests.
Were you watching a different race??Vanja #66 wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 18:49You know what, I agree. There definitely needs to be a protest, Norris going off track to overtake was a clear 10s penalty that simply had to be given. He released his brakes earlier than ever and had a throttle blip to get ahead of apex. I don't think he was making that corner, like Horner himself said.pantherxxx wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 14:52Apparently two stewards for the Mexican Grand Prix were Johnny Herbert and Tim Mayer (son of McLaren co-founder Teddy Mayer).
Do you remember that in 2021 they wanted to remove one of the stewards because he had a Honda dealership? Now British and Mclaren-linked stewards are punishing Max.
Red Bull should protest because of conflict of interests.
As I said before, T8 was a total sham penalty, Alonso in Norris' place would have gone wide and pull off a classic switchback. Max was completely ahead by the time they left the track
I actually only half agree with the reasoning from Stewards here.Mattchu wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 19:10Well the other two stewards were French and a Mexican and they fully agreed with the ruling, but I suppose there`s some bias in them as well! I mean, have some of you even read the what they said.
https://i.postimg.cc/YqvHs5Dq/t8.png
https://i.postimg.cc/wj5bfFzj/t4.png
How are we just brushing this off or making excuses...
You haven't completed the overtake, you were just entitled to the space but since you didn't manage to stay on track, the overtake is not complete and you need to give back the position. It's quite simple.langedweil wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 19:22Mattchu wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 19:10Well the other two stewards were French and a Mexican and they fully agreed with the ruling, but I suppose there`s some bias in them as well! I mean, have some of you even read the what they said.
https://i.postimg.cc/YqvHs5Dq/t8.png
How do you gain a position if you're already ahead ?
The key though is that Lando would have made the corner in T4 had he not been shoved off. Therefore it’s on Max to set himself up for a re-pass out of T5 when Lando would have had a too tight line into that corner. And this, ladies and gents, is what is called racing - battling each other on track by using the right strategy to place your car in the best way while giving room to your opponent. Lando wasn’t given room so he had to bail out and had all the right to keep that place.dialtone wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 19:28I actually only half agree with the reasoning from Stewards here.Mattchu wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 19:10Well the other two stewards were French and a Mexican and they fully agreed with the ruling, but I suppose there`s some bias in them as well! I mean, have some of you even read the what they said.
https://i.postimg.cc/YqvHs5Dq/t8.png
https://i.postimg.cc/wj5bfFzj/t4.png
How are we just brushing this off or making excuses...
Lando was 100% making the corner in T4 but he was so deep in T4 that he was gonna lose 2+ seconds to just turn the car and go back on the throttle out of T5 while Max was going to be able to make it more comfortably had he not totally fumbled the corner in irreparable ways. You can't judge this as a complete pass from Lando after you didn't judge the pass complete in Austin.
Lando definitely passed off track here and he shouldn't be getting an easy escape because he was pushed off, he gained 2+s by cutting that chicane even after giving the place back.
No, it isn't what it is. And you've really not been watching F1 if you think there hasn't been plenty of wheel to wheel racing.basti313 wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 13:59That is like believing in a Star Trek future.
This is not the reality in F1 for many years now. The last real wheel to wheel battle may have been Vettel vs. Webber with Multi21...Seanspeed wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 13:15Simply barging people off-track is not good racing, and is in fact depriving us of better, more exciting action. When drivers are allowed to go side by side through a corner, they can often carry that battle into the next series of corners, which makes for some of the best racing action possible.
...There should never be a reason in one on one battling for any car to be able to push another off-track, period.
Since 2014 especially the Merc officials strongly worked on the point that crowding your opponent on the exit is 100% acceptable as this was the signature move of Hamilton. Since then it is 100% ok to push on the outside in F1, the other driver needs to yield.
No. There is constant change since 2014 and every year you could see why any crowding at the outside is not good, but they still try to write rules about it. I think the divebombing thing mainly started with Dan...Max was the king on moving.
Yes, but it is what it is. Wheel to wheel is an unrealistic thought, if you look at DTM, which had the best wheel to wheel in the last years, it barely goes without touching.
So how does that reconcile with a week ago when Lando wasn't given room into T12 so he had to bail out and kept the position, and he was given a 10 second penalty? Or when George pushes Bottas off in COTA, didn't stay on track himself (Max stayed on track in Mexico), kept the position gained and was only given a 5 second penalty.Tvetovnato wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 19:54The key though is that Lando would have made the corner in T4 had he not been shoved off. Therefore it’s on Max to set himself up for a re-pass out of T5 when Lando would have had a too tight line into that corner. And this, ladies and gents, is what is called racing - battling each other on track by using the right strategy to place your car in the best way while giving room to your opponent. Lando wasn’t given room so he had to bail out and had all the right to keep that place.dialtone wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 19:28I actually only half agree with the reasoning from Stewards here.Mattchu wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 19:10Well the other two stewards were French and a Mexican and they fully agreed with the ruling, but I suppose there`s some bias in them as well! I mean, have some of you even read the what they said.
https://i.postimg.cc/YqvHs5Dq/t8.png
https://i.postimg.cc/wj5bfFzj/t4.png
How are we just brushing this off or making excuses...
Lando was 100% making the corner in T4 but he was so deep in T4 that he was gonna lose 2+ seconds to just turn the car and go back on the throttle out of T5 while Max was going to be able to make it more comfortably had he not totally fumbled the corner in irreparable ways. You can't judge this as a complete pass from Lando after you didn't judge the pass complete in Austin.
Lando definitely passed off track here and he shouldn't be getting an easy escape because he was pushed off, he gained 2+s by cutting that chicane even after giving the place back.
I did not say, there is no wheel to wheel. But if there is a 90° corner and one driver can push the other one off or at least try it...they do it and it is surprisingly allowed. A long and clean multi corner battle....i fear Multi21 was one of the last ones. Mexico turn 4 is an example where they try to push others wide since they drive there.Seanspeed wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 19:56No, it isn't what it is. And you've really not been watching F1 if you think there hasn't been plenty of wheel to wheel racing.basti313 wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 13:59That is like believing in a Star Trek future.
This is not the reality in F1 for many years now. The last real wheel to wheel battle may have been Vettel vs. Webber with Multi21...Seanspeed wrote: ↑28 Oct 2024, 13:15Simply barging people off-track is not good racing, and is in fact depriving us of better, more exciting action. When drivers are allowed to go side by side through a corner, they can often carry that battle into the next series of corners, which makes for some of the best racing action possible.
...There should never be a reason in one on one battling for any car to be able to push another off-track, period.
Since 2014 especially the Merc officials strongly worked on the point that crowding your opponent on the exit is 100% acceptable as this was the signature move of Hamilton. Since then it is 100% ok to push on the outside in F1, the other driver needs to yield.
No. There is constant change since 2014 and every year you could see why any crowding at the outside is not good, but they still try to write rules about it. I think the divebombing thing mainly started with Dan...Max was the king on moving.
Yes, but it is what it is. Wheel to wheel is an unrealistic thought, if you look at DTM, which had the best wheel to wheel in the last years, it barely goes without touching.
You also seem to think very poorly of all these drivers and their skill if you think they're literally incapable of driving cleanly.